Hello!
First time I answer a printer question on the boards but this question caught my attention because I was in the same boat a few years ago - and it can be daunting with so many options. I used to probably buy a new ink-jet printer every other year....

I purchased Canon, Epson, and an HP. All gave me trouble and I have to tell you, I'm a casual user. However, my brother-in-law [who's a computer/networking guy] told me to look into a Brother. He sent me a model to look at and 4-years later, it's still kicking strong. A great little all-in-one machine, paid less than $100.00 for it, and the ink is cheap through
http://www.1ink.com.
My machine's model # is MFC-295CN [which is discontinued at this point]. If the model that I have fits your needs, I would just compare the specs with a newer version.
I couldn't be happier with my Brother printer though. Hope this helps.