I enjoyed it, too, and didn't have any particular complaints when I visited. It was uncrowded and pleasant, with a few stand-outs, but with some obvious work to be done as it matures.
That said, we've recently been considering visiting Tokyo
Disneyland and Tokyo DisneySea. In the course of "working the numbers," I read a comment from someone had visited TDS during a preview of some type. The visitor said he had not been on any of the attractions or rides, but just walked through the park and enjoyed the experience of being completely transported to another place for the day.
I wondered about what kind of transforming experience one could have at DCA if they chose not to visit any attractions or rides, but just walked through the park and soaked up the theming. Would the theming of the park itself be satisfying enough to experience DCA for $43 without visitng any attractions or rides? The answer for me was no....not even on the most spectacular ride at DCA (Soarin') do you get the sense that the entire experience of the attraction is transforming.
After I read that comment, I went to look at the pictures of Tokyo DisneySea...and THAT'S when I got what people are complaining about at DCA. You really could visit this park without going on any attractions. It's amazing, and transforming, even without rides. That is the kind of experience that people were looking for at DCA, and have been disappointed not to find. *I* will go back to DCA, but I will carry with me the images of "what might have been" and what hopefully, someday, will be.
Click around here. I think you'll see what I mean:
http://www.jtcent.com/disneysea/index.html