ohhhhh lisa, why did you post those photos? i just got that tingly feeling seeing my room(s) at "home" again
so, just my opinion, but for a first time, i would request an upper floor - the view of illuminations if gorgeous on 5, and beautiful on 4.
we stay in xx29 or xx31 at least twice a year (just got back on may 1st <sigh>, am thinking of stopping by for a few days in august, and have our sept/oct trip booked
). for us, the second floor is wonderful: the balcony is HUUUUUGE, but our absolute favorite part is the very short walk up/down the stairwell. the nearby stairs - just around a corner from these rooms - exit to 2 doors: one leading to the main pool and the other by the walkway to DHS. since we like to go in and out of our room a lot (strolls, picking up something at the bakery, etc), the convenience of the stairwell overrides our love of that full, stunning view sometimes. (the walk down 5 flights of stairs is easy, but we learned that going up multiple times a day is just too much exercise. the elevators are not far, but just not as convenient).
you still do get a view of illuminations from the 2nd and 3rd floors, as well as being able to watch people playing (i.e., losing
) the carny games as well as seeing up close the awe and envy in people's faces as they wonder how you became so fortunate to have such a view, but simply, lluminations is more limited.
for a first timer (actually, for the first few trips), i would definately recommend requesting upper floor. if you can use stairs (are sans strollers, scooters, wheelchairs, knee/leg problems), the 2nd floor has some wonderful amenities all it's own.
have a wonderful trip