I thought it was carbonated too? It looks like it from your photo for sure I think the frozen butterbeer would be better like pp said. I do not believe the bottled pumpkin juice has carbonation though, maybe he would like that if he doesn't like the butterbeer.
Thank you. I'll think we'll try the frozen one He just freaks out when he gets something with carbonation (he has Asperger's syndrome), and he really wants to have butterbeer. I think he just wants the mug