I agree! We loved the frozen, but have no desire to have another of the regular. We'll be getting some frozen butterbeer in less than a month though. Can't wait! What I found gross was the pumpkin juice. I love pumpkin but hated that gritty stuff they call pumpkin juice at the Three Broomsticks.
I had both kinds and honestly, I much preferred the regular Butterbeer. The frozen gave me a brainfreeze and it did not mix as nicely with the topping.