We have stayed at BVS twice and just stayed at Caribe in July. If you want a great pool and slide go for Caribe!! The pool is so much nicer than Disney's moderate pools IMO. And the room to spread out is great. Both resorts rooms are the same, just different decorations. But the views from Caribe overlooking the pool was wonderful. And I don't know what kind of air freshener they use in the central air, but when you step off the elevators into a vestible/foyer on each floor the smell is wonderful. It was like being in the tropics. Coconut...ummm!!