I booked a trip in July with the old system and one in January using the online BRP system. The biggest difference in my experience has to do with the 60 day window- we came home from the World on June 5th and I called to book July 25-29 on June 6th and then called the next day(the 7th) to switch it to the 26-30 after buying airline tickets. That was a spontaneous trip that was planned within the 60 day window. Can't do that now.
When we got our airline tickets for October, we ended up having to add an extra night and it was in the "black hole" so we ended up adding it on points rather than switching to a cash ressie for the last night. Disney's got the money for the DVC points I own so they gained nothing(except for the extra food we bought at F&W fest) by essentially forcing my hand on using points rather than cash.
I'm a DVC member with an AP(PAP actually) and everyone in the party I usually travel with also has their own. I don't buy the AP for room discounts but having them available does affect my decisions about extra trips above and beyond what I would do using just my points. Disney can definitely make more money on me by encouraging more frequent trips with discounted room rates so I'm glad that some sort of program is available. I just wish they would do something about the 60 day window as I can see that being a problem again in the future.
When we got our airline tickets for October, we ended up having to add an extra night and it was in the "black hole" so we ended up adding it on points rather than switching to a cash ressie for the last night. Disney's got the money for the DVC points I own so they gained nothing(except for the extra food we bought at F&W fest) by essentially forcing my hand on using points rather than cash.
I'm a DVC member with an AP(PAP actually) and everyone in the party I usually travel with also has their own. I don't buy the AP for room discounts but having them available does affect my decisions about extra trips above and beyond what I would do using just my points. Disney can definitely make more money on me by encouraging more frequent trips with discounted room rates so I'm glad that some sort of program is available. I just wish they would do something about the 60 day window as I can see that being a problem again in the future.