well to play devil's advocate, and to add in my 2 cents, I would like to offer a differing opinion.
I have to disagree that you don't really miss out on anything if you always do the buffet instead of the dining rooms, although I do see some benefits to those with small children being able to get food quickly with minimal fuss. Also those couples without children who just "vant to be alone.." If you are looking to get food fast, get done and then high tail it out of there, then yes that probably is the best option.
I think everything about the dining experience just furthers your experience on the boat as well. The ambiance is difinately different in the dining areas from the buffet. Yes, you can still get some of the same menus, but keep in mind that the company of the table, your servers that you have all week, and the presentation of the food, is also part of the experience. This is especially true of Animator's Palace.
Just my opinion,
Lynne