Trattoria al Forno is new, so it sounds interesting. I didn't think the food at 'Ohana was that great and kind of limited. It's really family style, not a true buffet. We like the breakfast buffets better, because there are more food choices for our picky DS. It looks like Trattoria isn't a true buffet either though, but I think the choices look better there. Unless you have a preference on the characters, I would choose Trattoria al Forno. We are also doing a character breakfast buffet before our cruise in August. We are doing 1900 Park Fare, because we love the food and characters and it's our tradition.