1) Book thru Disney as a package
We've did this on our last trip. We actually went through aaa to get the enhanced fastpass even though it was cheaper by $4 to go through the
disneyland website. It was a a great experience since disney sends out a really cool gold envelope filled with all the details of your pacakage, including hotel vouchers, actual parkhoppers, lugage tags, and vouchers for pins and lanyards. We did pay a couple hundred dollars more than if we were to have pieced it together seperately. however, by going through aaa, we got little perks like toontown morning madness, preferred seating at dca shows and pins & lanyards.
2) Book through a travel agent
Not exactly a travel agent (dealing through one person) but we've booked through getawaytoday.com in the past for a hotel on harbor. Our package included 2 free adult parkhoppers so we only had to buy 1 child hopper for our son. It was cheaper to do it this way than to book hotel and purchase hopper seperately. We're using them again for our trip in March since expedia and the disneyland website were showing our dates as unavailable for the DLH. This time around, we didn't need the free parkhoppers so that was deducted from our total bill. It was actually cheaper to go through getawaytoday for hotel than to go through exepdia or disneyland.com since all taxes and resort fees were included in the final cost.
3) Do things on your own (separate pieces - hotel, air, tickets)??
We've always purchased airfares seperately. For our Aug trip, we're going this route. We've already made our hotel reservations and are waiting to see if airfares go down.
Our main thing when booking is figuring out what are needs are. If we are doing a budget trip, then i scour the internet finding the best deals. If we feel like we want certain perks that are only available by booking via aaa or WDTC, then we go that route. There is no one right answer.
Also, any good hotel suggestions within easy walking distance??
We've stayed at BW Park Place Inn (literally across the crosswalk) and the Tropicana and have liked. Most people on these boards recommend howard johnson and candy cane inn.