We always make a trip (or two!) to Boatwrights every time we are at WDW. We love it. Great atmosphere and the service we have had, has always been great. Cant say much about the food choices though, we go to Boatwrights strickly for the steak! We have been to most of the restaurants and steakhouses at WDW, and Boatwrights always has the best prime rib on property for the money, IMHO. Its a bargain compared to Prime rib any where else on property, and its great. We dont even look at the menu anymore......we all just order the PR.
So, while we dont know about some of the other food choices at Boatwrights, we can attest that the steak is awesome! Also, its a very easy ADR to get at the last minute.
Good luck.......