I'd encourage you to give it a chance in person. Maybe you don't like the headboard, but man, I bet you love the soft, comfortable, bedding! And the kitchen...just wait until it's time to make something in the kitchen and more than 1 person can move around, or you have a place to put all your food without having to stack stuff on top of the fridge!
I agree, the decor just isn't for everyone. It is my absolute favorite - I think Disney does a good job of themeing resorts, but I've never been a fan of the heavy mix of patterns in the resorts - I think the old Boardwalk Inn decor minus the postcard drapes was my favorite, and it was probably the most low-key. BLT came along and it was perfect for me - modern decor like I'd find in a W Hotel, but with the monorail with some seriously cool Disney artwork and touches.