It's just a coincidence probably, it was from a party about 2 years ago in the Freehold area. It just made me feel as if my gift was not up to snuff, even though I appreciated the goodies from the party.
LOL, thats when our party was...and we live in Freehold. This is one big coincidence!
This is really freaky, what are the odds.
Its a small world after all... Its a small world after all.... its a small, small world....
I told him to avail himself of the anonimity the internet can offer -- he chose a new name. 
Different party. 