I turned/adjusted the coldness to as cold as possible and no luck. I did that as soon as we loaded the fridge as I could tell it wasn't very cold.
The main difference between a beverage cooler and fridge is the temperature control settings and ability to consistently hold temperature. To keep bacteria away and keep the items fresh, refrigerators usually operate at a temperature below 39 degrees F while most beverage coolers are 40 degrees and up. They can look pretty similar so it isn't necessarily apparent upon glance. We haven't had a problem when staying at BCV but with this stay at the Poly for 8 days we ended up losing some of our groceries (milk/yogurt) due to not cold enough temp.
I just did a bit more googling and found this direct on Disney's website: (
https://disneyworld.disney.go.com/guest-services/refrigerators/)
"Feel at ease over the course of your vacation with convenient coolers, located right in your room! Many of our
Disney Resort hotels come equipped with either an in-room refrigerator or a small beverage cooler"
I guess that would indicate it's the luck of the draw with what you get?