I've not stayed at the Poly, but it does look really nice and gets great reviews. That said, I'm one of those that never wants to stay in the same place twice. Part of the fun is trying out the different resorts. So, my vote would be to try something new. We were at the Dolphin last November and really enjoyed it. The location is great! POR or POFQ would be great, too, and are on my 'to-try' list!