Raglan Road hands down. Every time we go (which has been several, spread out over a lot of years) the service is terrific, entertainment is fun, and the food is delicious. Plate clearing delicious.
RC
I had dreams about the pot roast at 50s Prime Time Café for months. No kidding. I went back on a second trip and it was much less awesome. Sigh. Otherwise Be Our Guest dinner was probably our favorite this trip.
To the OP, Chef Mickey is only worth it for the characters, really, but it wasn't bad by any means.
Dinner: Raglan Road
Breakfast: Kona Cafe
Character meal: Crystal palace breakfast
We also really enjoy Wolfgang Puck express (the pizza and creme brulee- yum).
Three places we go to every year if we can:
garden Grill: First time I ate there , I loved the salad and I don't eat healthy green stuff
Cape may café: Love crab legs
Hollywood and vine lunch: I have o idea why this place gets bad reviews we love it and never had a bad meal here and while my DS likes the characters too we will go until the characters no longer interest him
Breakfast - Captains Grill or Trails End
Lunch - Sanaa Hands down for food, ambiance and an awesome view
Dinner - Artist Point for upscale, and a carry out chicken dinner from Trails End to eat on a picnic table by the marina at Ft Wilderness when you want to feed the family for <$30 and the kids just can't sit still for one more restaurant dinner! We love Tusker for non character buffet at dinner.
Best Princess Dining- Norway without a doubt. Loved the food at lunch and more princess time than anyplace else