Best childrens' cold medicine?

Jrsy Boy

DIS Veteran
Joined
Feb 28, 2005
Messages
3,626
I am completely frustrated by the childrens' cold medicines that don't seem to do anything that they claim. The only ones we've had any success with are Umcka and Chestal brands, which I think are both supposed to be homeopathic. Are there any cold medicines for children that really do what they claim?
 
I have never given my kids cold medicine. As far as I am concerned, they don't need it. And the new studies and recommendations regarding cold meds for kids under 2, have me questioning whether they are appropriate for older kids, too.

Denae
 
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS URGES CAUTION IN USE OF OVER-THE-COUNTER COUGH AND COLD MEDICINES



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

For Immediate Release: January 17, 2008

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration today issued an advisory strongly recommending that over-the-counter cough and cold medications not be given to infants and children under two years old because of the risk of life-threatening side effects. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) supports this recommendation and urges parents to seek safer ways to soothe infants and young children suffering from colds and coughs.

Studies have shown cough and cold products are ineffective in treating symptoms of children under six years old, and may pose serious risks. A variety of rare, serious health problems have been associated with use of these medications in children, including death, convulsions, rapid heart rates and decreased levels of consciousness. (A review by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention of national emergency department visits due to adverse drug events from cough and cold medications will be published in the online version of Pediatrics Jan. 28.)

“It is critically important for parents to receive clear information about the risks and lack of benefit from these drugs, and ways to help take care of children suffering from colds and coughs,” said Renee Jenkins, M.D., FAAP, president of the American Academy of Pediatrics. “We urge FDA to continue its analysis of the existing data on these medicines intended for children over age 2 and take appropriate action, including initiation of immediate, rigorous scientific studies as needed to determine the drugs’ safety and efficacy.”

Children metabolize and react to medications differently than adults, often in unanticipated ways. For more than 30 years the AAP has emphasized the importance of studying medicines in pediatric populations. As part of the FDA’s ongoing review of over-the-counter cough and cold medications, the AAP in October urged regulators to pursue further studies into whether these drugs have any benefit to children. The AAP also advised labeling that would inform parents that the products have been shown to be ineffective in children under 6 and could lead to serious adverse reactions. Thursday’s advisory is an important first step. The FDA expects to announce its recommendation for children ages 2 to 11 in early spring.

While annoying, cough and cold symptoms are usually benign and self-limiting. Over-the-counter cough and cold medications will not cure these illnesses nor shorten their duration. Parents should seek safer ways to nurse their children back to health, Dr. Jenkins said.

“Although these medications have been in use for a long time, now we’ve learned they have some risks, especially because of the difficulty in determining a safe and accurate dose for small children,” Dr. Jenkins said. “Instead of drugs, there are symptomatic interventions parents can do that are much safer for children.”

Dr. Jenkins recommended saline nose drops and suctioning bulbs to thin and clear mucus from a baby’s nose, and using a cool-mist humidifier. Chest physical therapy can also loosen mucus and may help infants and young children expel mucus. If a child under age 2 develops a fever, consult a pediatrician. For more suggestions on treating children without over-the-counter cough and cold drugs, www.aap.org/publiced/BR_Infections.htm
 
To clarify, my son is 11 and I wouldn't expect him to suffer with congestion, runny nose and coughing any more than I'd suffer through it drug-free myself. I'm just looking for something that is going to help him, not a reprimand for trying.
 

The "new" Sudafed is working for us. Sudafed PE it says 12 to Adult my DS is 10 & my Dr BIL say he could take it. It just 1 pill.

Kae
 
I try not to give my DD8 cold medicine especially during the day. But at nighttime if she couldn't sleep because she was so stuffed up and coughing I'd give her Tylenol cough and cold. I'd also use a Vicks plug in. Both seemed to help sooth her enough so she could sleep. I think the most important thing is to find something that just treats what's wrong without anything extra.
 
I have 5 and 7 yo DD's and I just rely on my old standby when they have colds/congestion. I put a little Vick's on their chest AND their back around the ribcage, some under their noses, and then run the vaporizer. Plenty of clear liquids, and I have found that helps better than any OTC meds because you're right, none of them do what they claim. Some of the allergy stuff is ok - I do like Benedryl for when they're sniffly and congested, but other than that, nothing much else really touches it.

I've also heard that if you put Vick's on the bottom of your feet and then cover with socks before bed, it does wonders. Mine haven't been sick since I've heard this, but I will definitely try it next time.

Good luck!
 
OP, are you sure its just a cold and not the flu or another infection that requires antibiotics? Now having covered that base here is how we handle the common cold. We use vicks vapo rub on nose, chest and bottoms of the feet, covering the feet with warm socks. We also use saline to flush the nasal passages, a hot shower is also good for this! A humidifier is great to eleviate dry air and you can add some eucalyptus to the water to help open up those stuffy noses and chests. We also administer claritan to help dry up mucus. If your son is old enough/weight wise he can take an adult dose of claritan-D. Tylenol or Motrin for pain, fever and aches and lots and lots of fluids. My kids know when they are sick that they can have 7-up, popsickles and push-ups as much as they want. I also serve them dry toast/saltines and chicken broth or soup. We really try and avoid a lot of the OTC meds and try and stick with the tried and true home remedies. We are actually doctoring for colds right now. Ours seems to start with a 24 hr low grade fever followed by aches, congestion and sneezing. In three days time we have gone thru 2 boxes of kleenex and half a jar of vicks and I just went out a restocked fridge and freezer with 7-up and push-ups. Our kids are 1,3,10 and 12. The 1 and 3 year old are doing better today, the 10 yr old is on the cough in the game room. His fever broke early this morning and the 12 yr old seems ok. Will see how she feels when she gets home from school but she thought she felt fine when she left this morning!

Good luck in your search for the perfect cold meds! I swear by claritan. I have also used nitequil for myself in the past but they have since changed their formula so im not sure. But I know when I was down and out that stuff put me to sleep and I felt much better after two days of rest. Unfortunately, I dont have 2 days of such luxury anymore with 4 kids roaming our abode...lol!

I hope your little guy is feeling better real soon!
 
To clarify, my son is 11 and I wouldn't expect him to suffer with congestion, runny nose and coughing any more than I'd suffer through it drug-free myself. I'm just looking for something that is going to help him, not a reprimand for trying.


I usually ask my pharmacist for a suggestion. He gives good advice on what works and what is not worth our time and/or money. I try not to give too much during the day but my thought is that if they can't rest at night they will have a much harder time getting better. We also do all the stuff someone else mentioned- humidifier, a bit of vapo rub on the chest or under the nose for stuffy nose stuff, saline nose drops, etc.... My kids also like a warm bath with the vapor bath stuff. Since your son is older, if you look at Whole Foods Market, you can buy a cold & flu bubble bath/body wash made by Kiss My Face. It comes in a clear squeeze top container and it is soothing to sit in a bubble bath of it when you're feeling crappy.

Good luck and I hope he feels better soon!:hug:
 
I find that Delsym seems to work for coughs on my 9 yr old. Plain sudafed also works for the stuffy noses.

Crissi
 
Thanks for the info, everyone. He is definitely better this week; it was last week when he missed three days of school and was miserable. Turns out he wasn't the only one. I guess it is that time of year.:sick:
 
I have had great success with a line called Herbs for Kids. I started using them on my daughter when she was about 2 years old. They've worked like a charm!
 
Thanks for the info, everyone. He is definitely better this week; it was last week when he missed three days of school and was miserable. Turns out he wasn't the only one. I guess it is that time of year.:sick:

This time of year stinks, it seems that one of us always has *something* going on:sad2:
 
Per our pediatrician, you should only use the individual cold remedies as needed to treat symptoms... a decongestant to treat sinus congestion, an expectorant to treat chest congestion, a cough suppressant to sleep when you have a bad cough, and tylenol for pain/fever. Ever since that recommendation, we don't buy the "one medicine cures all" mixes.

For both the children and adults in our house, I stock Sudafed (phenelephrine doesn't work, gotta go to the pharmacy counter for the good stuff) and Guefenesin (sp?, the 12 hour Mucinex is amazing) in addition to Tylenol. My kids have viral-induced asthma and seem to pick up every cold out there. We go through a lot of meds and it's taken me years to find out what works the best.

I hope your son is feeling better soon!
 
I have a few things that I like for colds and flu. I also love the Herbs for Kids line, and often give dd the Sweet Echinacea. My dd is only a year and a half though..I'm not sure how well it works for older kids, who are almost old enough for the adult meds. For me I love Umcka...and they also have a kids version for kids 2 and up (I order mine online at seacoastvitamins.com). It works best when taken at the first sign of the cold or flu (they have a regular cold version, and also a cold and flu one). It can definitely help ward off the cold/flu, or at least shorten the duration and severity of it.
 













Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE














DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top