Beaches & Cream OR the Plaza?

[Mommymcgee]

Which is better foodwise and which has better ice cream?

 

[OKW Lover]

The ice cream is the same at both. We like B&C food and atmosphere better.

 

[minnierocks]

Personally, I would go to the Plaza for a couple of reasons...

1) It's in the park, so I don't have to make a trip somewhere else. Beaches and Cream was OK, but I would only eat there if I was staying there.

2) The seating is VERY limited at Beaches and Cream, so there is almost always a wait. The Plaza will take ADR's, so...no waiting for me!

Plus, I liked the Plaza's milkshakes better, along with the menu options were better (I loved the strawberry salad)...