Bat magic for 2 snowman magic?

[AllisonY2K]

Two things that I encountered in a trade room and just wanted some clarification on from you trading gurus here:

1. Is it fair (and would someone take me up on it?) to ask for 2 1-star snowman magic pins for 1 1-star bat magic pin? I figured since bat was 10K credits and snowman is 5K credits that 2 snowman pins would be equal to 1 bat magic and it would be an even trade, credit-wise.

2. someone tried to tell me that pirate wells are more rare than bat magic. seeing that I have 2 pirate wells already I declined the offer, but is that true?

thanks in advance for your replies!!

 

[leafygreen]

Two things that I encountered in a trade room and just wanted some clarification on from you trading gurus here:

1. Is it fair (and would someone take me up on it?) to ask for 2 1-star snowman magic pins for 1 1-star bat magic pin? I figured since bat was 10K credits and snowman is 5K credits that 2 snowman pins would be equal to 1 bat magic and it would be an even trade, credit-wise.

2. someone tried to tell me that pirate wells are more rare than bat magic. seeing that I have 2 pirate wells already I declined the offer, but is that true?

thanks in advance for your replies!!

Just my 2 cents...
1. I would do that trade. I guess it also depend on the people trading.

2. As other people have mentioned before the worth is subjective, especially since the magic could be bought but the wells couldn't in game.

 

[ScooterJake]

Here is my two credits worth.

While the credits spent is the same there will more than likely be more snowman magics out there now that it has been sold for the second time. Because it was cheaper than the bat more ppl were probably able to buy the snowman and more of them.

As for the wells. They are not that rare at all. The code cards are still available in great numbers at the parks. We were just in WDW Dec 3-10 and there was a big stack of them at the register in the pirate gift shop at the end of the POTC attraction. People have gotten these cards in huge numbers and they are not a valuable item to bargain with in trades. If you would like a well seat PM me and I will meet you in the kingdom and give you one.

 

[disvaclub92]

I will take you up on that trade. Just PM me when you are on.

 

[groovyguestgirl]

1. Bat Magic for 2 Snowman Magics? I would not trade the Bat Magic. They add up to the same amount of credits, but Bat Magic was sold earlier and for more credits, so less people could buy it at Halloween. It was also sold with the Halloween Costumes, which made a lot of people waste their credits on

2. Wells? They aren't really that rare. They had a mistake for a while, and they somehow printed codes for wells on the quest cards. I once traded a 50th Celebration Pin to someone, for 6 wells.

But what it all really comes down to is that there is no 'worth'. It's worth is technically just what you think it is.

 

[birdmom]

I had no bat magics when snow man came out. Now I have three and they we all gotten in a two for on snowman trade, I am still looking for bat if anyone wants two snowman magic for it.