Thanks so much for all of the great suggestions. I'm going to start googling and checking them all out now.
I knew Bitty Baby would get lots of votes.
I had forgotton about the Madame A baby dolls.
My girls have had those (I think Baby Huggums was our 1st baby doll ever), the Carolle baby dolls, a chou chou baby, and Bitty Baby.
I don't think you could go wrong with any of them. Just be sure to get one that "fits".
Personally for a toddler I like really soft & squishy or beanbag type bodies, they just seem so much easier to love on.
For girls who are a bit older or who want to do lots of playing mommy ie: having the doll sit in a high chair to feed her and such, then making sure the doll will sit and reposition without falling over is important.
Good Luck in your search.
Be sure to check back in and let us know what you think.
Edited to add: I just checked out the link to the reborn dolls. What sweet babies!
jrasmom, Bitty Baby is an American Girl doll. You have to order her online or from their catalog.