Michael and I got married in November 2003. Our 5-course menu cost $68 per person (this does not include CH, cake or bar).
We had:
Canadian Cheddar Cheese Soup (Mike's favorite thing in Disney - it came straight from Canada)
Caesar Salad witha Parmesan Cheese Fan and housemade croutons
Blood Orange Sorbet Intermezzo in a Sugar rimmed martini glass
Duet of Filet Mignon and Parmesan Crusted Chicken
Garlic Mashed potatoes in a potato nest and haricots verts
Cinderella's White Chocolate Slipper Dessert
While we had 5 courses, we did not serve very expensive choices - soup is cheaper than Shrimp Cocktail, we did not serve lobster, etc.
Our food was wonderful - Michelle Dorr worked with me to come up with a menu that would reflect our tastes and appeal to our guests.
If there are things you like, tell your WP. If you have a maximum price you want to spend, share that as well.
I did not limit myself to the Boardwalk menus. Other than the slipper, our menu was custom.
Good luck!