Anyone worried about being "priced out" of Disney?

Is that what you tell the server if there is a required tip printed on the bill?

Suggested NOT required, if you read... There are two amounts.....I leave cash and don't have to " tell " anything, I leave what I wish, be it the 18% or the 20 % or 15 % for a buffet, point is, I choose.
End of discussion I don't have to answer to the dis board tipping police
 
Suggested NOT required, if you read... There are two amounts.....I leave cash and don't have to " tell " anything, I leave what I wish, be it the 18% or the 20 % or 15 % for a buffet, point is, I choose.
End of discussion I don't have to answer to the dis board tipping police

:rotfl:
 
Glad you found it funny....whatever :rotfl:

in any event, back to the original question....I enjoy WDW and have found it is because of discounts that I have been blessed to be able to do 3 trips since 2008. If prices keep rising, and they do away with room pins or free dining, or other incentives to make the trip affordable, then....yes, I might need to pull in on the visits....I am happy that I have gotten sme kind of pin or free dining for all my trips, except my first when I knew nothing about discounts and let AMA book it ( equivalent to aaa)
 
Yep, you can see it in their faces. We were at Wolfgang Puck's restaurant and, after seeing folks that looked like they just came from a tattoo convention or a biker club meeting sit next to us, the server came up and, after welcoming us asked about any dining plan, as if to prepare for the puzzle he must put together . When we said we were just paying cash, his face literally changed, as if to say..."ah, real customers, with real money." It was if we were his special friends at that point. Some restaurants have refused DDP, perhaps out of respect for their servers.

I have been a server for many years. those of us servers "in the know" will trip over each other to get that "biker" table. generally speaking, bikers are very good tippers.
 
I dislike posts like this as you provide no proof. This is a common post on the cruise boards. We are cruising in June 2012 on the brand-new Disney Fantasy for 7-night eastern in two rooms (one verandah, one inside). I priced identical cruises leaving on the same day or within one day of Disney on 70night Eastern. On the first day of booking for Carnival, the price was just a bit more than what we are paying. On the first day of cruising for Royal Caribbean, the price is anywhere from $400 to $1,300 more depending on the ship.

A Carnival cruise for 2 rooms Aug. 13 going to the Bahamas for 5 nights is $2271. A Disney cruise for Aug. 10 5 nights to the Bahamas for 2 rooms comes to $4978.96. If you can find me a Disney cruise for $1,135.56 for one room 5 nights- please help me find it. Maybe you know more tricks of the trade. (going out of Florida)

I think you were referring to my post, but the premise is incorrect. I've never said that a Disney cruise is cheaper than some other cruise. What I was saying was that our Disney cruise in September of 2010 was cheaper than a WDW vacation- if everything was included. There were various cheaper Carnival cruises available, but since we were a Disney family, we decided to have our first cruise on a Disney boat to ease the transition. We had a fantastic time!

Now this year, we went on a Carnival cruise- just to see if we would like cruising without the Disney stuff. We did, but there are caveats. For instance, there were times when we were walking around the Carnival ship with nothing to do. That's almost impossible on a Disney cruise. But you do pay for that Disney stuff.

Now next year, we're contemplating going on a Royal Caribbean cruise. It looks like there so much to do. Plus, they are ripping off Disney by having their Dreamworks characters aboard. I even heard that they are having a "Sail Away Celebration" aboard- complete with dancing characters and cruise personnel singing and dancing! Just like Disney!

But if you're looking for a cheaper cruise- you can't get any cheaper than Carnival. And you will have a good time. We did.
 
I have been a server for many years. those of us servers "in the know" will trip over each other to get that "biker" table. generally speaking, bikers are very good tippers.

Sorry for my poor description, I was telling two different stories there and wasn't really clear. One is about the reaction after telling server about no DDP, the other is about what we've noticed in general about people not either dressed or acting appropriately for the surroundings. I wasn't trying to imply that the next table would be a bad tip, just paint the picture of the things happening in Disney restaurants (in this case two different things, sorry i wasn't clear). It was a bad description, I wish I could give a better one, I'm pretty sure they didn't drive motorcycles. (I've amended my original post) But it was very clear to many in that restaurant (because of some turning heads and following eyeballs) that pretty much anything goes at Disney restaurants these days. I guess you could make the same comparison to airplanes.
 
I believe that was your way of disagreeing with servers and other posters direct testimony. Apparently you don't believe that if you suddenly open up the gates to those who otherwise wouldn't be there, that you can't possibly have anyone out of place there, even if only a small percentage of those new arrivals. That just could never happen. I mean, that just never happens in any other situation, how could it happen at Disney...isn't that what you're saying?

I get your point, but I really don't think that it has that much bearing given the current state of free dining. The fact that the values get the quick service plan and the cost of upgrading to the basic plan gets higher every year seems to me like it would "filter out" those people who aren't sufficiently accustomed to sit down meals to know and adhere to the norms of tipping.

I would think a bigger factor than free dining would be the different cultural norms about tipping, around the country and around the world, and how those expectations have changed over time. It wasn't that long ago that 15% was considered a good tip; when I started driving, the little "tip card" that someone gave me listed 10% & 15%, now they list 15% & 20%, but a lot of people still cling to those old habits. Add in guests from foreign countries where tipping isn't handled the same way as here in the states and you have a lot of people who are apt not to realize what is expected (though I think by printing the suggested tip amounts on the receipt Disney does the best they can to let guests know).
 
Out of morbid curiosity (and I know I shouldn't have done this) I looked at the price of tickets throughout history and noticed that they are way out of whack with respect to inflation. My first trip to DL as an adult it cost $31... and that was only in 1994, now it's $80 (non-park hopper for comparison purposes). My only trip to WDW was in 2000 (I remember due to the 2000 they had on top of Epcot) a 4 day park hopper cost around $170, today almost $300.



So does anyone else think about this? Or is it best just to hand over your money and forget how much things cost "back in the day" :rotfl:

I have not read all the replies so I apologize if this has been repeated a million times.

I don't really do "back in the day" as far as prices go, but my downfall is I compare disney "back in the day" in relation to value and quality.

Disney has not outpriced me yet but it has "outquality" me. For my dollars the value vs. cost is slowly dimishing.

Its funny with so many cruises and all inclusives offering "more" for your money disney seems to be raising prices and offering "less".

Last May, I went to Paris for almost the same price as disney (2 days less in Paris). The food was 1000X's better, the hotel was a 1000X's better and we had just as much fun. This was including r/t airfare from NYC. Now granted it was a totally different type of vacation but every night I left the restaurants saying how absolutely fabulous the meal was, that no longer happens in Disney and the hotel staff tripped over themselves to cater to my family.

We're skipping Disney next year so hopefully absence will make my heart grow fonder.
 
Well, going back to what I believe is the original intent of this discussion, here are some of my thoughts:

Right now, for my family of five, a 8 night Disney vacation is still a lower cost option than other vacations that we are looking into, but only with the right Disney discount. (Free dining in 2012 can save us around $1500 if offered, versus buying the plan outright) Room discounts don't save us all that much since we stay at value resorts, or moderates. Without discounts, Disney is more than a 7 night Caribbean Cruise on Royal Caribbean (inside state rooms), or a 8 night stay on-site at US/IoA/ with a couple of days at Seaworld. So without discounts, Disney doesn’t necessarily price me out of a Disney vacation, but it will make me look harder at other options such as a cruise or other locations like US/IoA/Seaworld. So in some sense, it wouldn’t price me out of Disney rather than push me somewhere else. Our kids have a great time at Disney, and when we can go there at less cost than our other options, it makes it tough to turn down. If Disney prices outpace other vacation options or desinations, we will look elsewhere to spend our vacation dollars.

Now off subject: As for the free dining plan, and its impact on servers… it is also bringing more people into the TS restaurants which equals more potential for servers to get tips. Also, I have a VERY hard time believing that just because someone is on the dining plan, that they won’t tip decent. Where is the proof of this? Also, even during free dining offers, there are still those that buy the dining plan since a room discount can be a better offer in the deluxe resorts. I’ve had the free dining plan both of my last two trips, and our wait staff has always been very friendly even when we mention that we're on the dining plan. (in full disclosure, we travel in a party of 7 so there is an automatic 18% gratuity). If the free dining plan impact on servers is such a big issue for some, or how some people look at TS restaurants :rolleyes2 (proper dress attire at Disney is different than at your typical sit down restaurant), I suggest you go take up the subject in the Dining forums. :offtopic:

Dan
 
I have been a server for many years. those of us servers "in the know" will trip over each other to get that "biker" table. generally speaking, bikers are very good tippers.



Haha, that was my thought too. I used to work in a steakhouse and they were generally less demanding, fun to wait on, and left AWESOME tips.
 
I wonder how attendance now compares to mid 90s. It seems more crowded to me. Going back to my economics 101, I would say they price their tickets based on demand rather than the inflation rate (which by the way is an arbitrary number in many respects). Personally, I would be willing to pay more in order to have fewer guests in the parks. I would also be willing to pay more if it would mean bringing back the standards of quality from the mid 90s.
 
I agree with pp that this discussion needs to go back to the original question and not "types of people" and "tipping".
 
We are trying to plan for a trip for next year. We have 5 children(2 of which will count as adult pricing cause they are 10 & 12). Luckily one if under 3 but we have to buy tickets for 6 people. Its nuts.
Dh is not impressed with the cost of tickets
 
I'm sure there are lots of folks that have been priced out for a while. My younger sister (with my 2 nieces) is in poor financial straits so I've been buying their 3 tickets for some time now. I just can't bear their not having the experiences. I usually take them around MNSSHP and Christmas, since one niece has a birthday at the beginning of October and the other at the beginning of December.
 
Dh is not impressed with the cost of tickets

Ditto my Dh. Plus we have five kids who're "Disney adults", and they normally pay their own way -- they're not impressed with the cost of tickets, either. :upsidedow An Orlando vacation is really pricy for us -- we're more "National Parks/Week at the beach/do the resort activities" kind of people as a rule, and our memberships in various local museums and whatnot get us into zoos, museums, gardens, historical centers and science centers for free (or very discounted if we have to pay). So we'll maybe splurge on one thing the whole week, and that one thing historically has been pretty moderately priced -- Ripley's Aquarium in Gatlinburg, for instance.

So even if we do two days at SeaWorld, we're paying a lot more than normal. Tickets for two days at WDW, let alone enough days to really enjoy it? :scared1: The older kids can swing it pretty easily, since they can all get part-time jobs and don't have to depend on their allowance, but the younger three are not excited about dedicating half their allowance to a WDW ticket.

So our next Orlando trip will be the first one everyone goes to WDW -- the kids outvoted me and we did SeaWorld the last two times, although I did get some Disney time in both years, but in 2013 their dad's going to pay for part of their tickets and we're all doing WDW for six days minimum, at least one day in each park. :cool1: Whether they want to, or not. :rotfl:

By 2015 the kids will either pay their own way or not go, but I expect I'll still be going for a good while yet. Disney's got a lock on something I really like. I won't say it'll never get too expensive for us, but I don't see it happening in the next decade or so. Although if the kids or hubby get bit by the Disney bug I'll be spending a lot more time there than if I remain the only rabid fan. :p

But we're fortunate that, for us, it's more about, "Why spend all that money when we have such a great time going cheaper?" than about "Can we scrape up the cash?" I think Disney's already priced itself well out of reach for a lot of people. :sad1:
 
I think you were referring to my post, but the premise is incorrect. I've never said that a Disney cruise is cheaper than some other cruise. What I was saying was that our Disney cruise in September of 2010 was cheaper than a WDW vacation- if everything was included. There were various cheaper Carnival cruises available, but since we were a Disney family, we decided to have our first cruise on a Disney boat to ease the transition. We had a fantastic time!

Now this year, we went on a Carnival cruise- just to see if we would like cruising without the Disney stuff. We did, but there are caveats. For instance, there were times when we were walking around the Carnival ship with nothing to do. That's almost impossible on a Disney cruise. But you do pay for that Disney stuff.

Now next year, we're contemplating going on a Royal Caribbean cruise. It looks like there so much to do. Plus, they are ripping off Disney by having their Dreamworks characters aboard. I even heard that they are having a "Sail Away Celebration" aboard- complete with dancing characters and cruise personnel singing and dancing! Just like Disney!

But if you're looking for a cheaper cruise- you can't get any cheaper than Carnival. And you will have a good time. We did.



I challenge anybody to manage a disney trip for less than DH and I can manage. 33 year castmember discounts for rooms are tremendous, free park passes, discounts for food across the board, BIG discounts for shopping. Last trip we had free airfare and free car rental from my travel perks. Plus, we are rabid - old-time disney nuts....we met standing in line at BTMRR 7 years ago.

Having said that, we returned from our annual pilgrimage to WDW in early December and were just not thrilled with the downslide---especially at the holidays. Just too much lost value in our 8 night stay.

I noodled around for less than an hour last december and now in 32 days we will be leaving on a 12 night caribbean cruise, beautiful suite. When you add all the expenses --- travel, night ahead at port, excursions, gratuities and compare the 12 night cost to 8 nights of wicked good discounts at WDW....guess what.

It's a pinch less to cruise for 12 nights + night ahead than our 8 night castmember discounted trip to WDW last December. This isn't a budget cruiseline....just a great discount.

Now....somebody tell me again about the great value of a Disney trip. HAHAHAHAHA.......


As much as we adore our trips to Disney......there are simply too many other places to go which are fabulous.....cost less......better service......cleaner. Hum, I guess Disney has NOT held it's value well.
 
my bf and I want to go back either next december or december 2013. i don't know how people can afford to go a few times a year. it's expensive!
 
I totally agree about the pricing going up. However, after a recent trip to Six Flags, I wanted to point out that the value of Disney CS food - in comparison to other theme parks - is EXCELLENT.

For example:

In MK at Cosmic Ray's, a bacon cheeseburger and fries is $9.19. You can get that and a free ice water and have a meal for under $10.

The same meal at six flags was $14.99. In one day at Six Flags, I spent almost twice as much on food as I do at MK.


Last year, I took 16 teens to WDW and gave them dining cards with $25 a day for food. I told them about free ice water and told them that they might want to choose between a soda at a meal OR a treat later. The kids were able to have two meals and 1-2 snacks this way. In fact, sometimes we would split meals in order to "snack around the world".

For an EIGHT DAY TRIP, we spent $300 per person on food. This included:

HDDR (Best Seats)
CP Character Breakfast
Rainforest Cafe Breakfast
12 CS Meals
Snacks at the parks
Breakfast items from grocery store at hotel

At another park, it could easily be double this.

To echo what others have said, a lot of this is budgeting. We are going this year for 11 days and will spend $360 per person including CRT and Via Napoli!
 
I think you were referring to my post, but the premise is incorrect. I've never said that a Disney cruise is cheaper than some other cruise. What I was saying was that our Disney cruise in September of 2010 was cheaper than a WDW vacation- if everything was included. There were various cheaper Carnival cruises available, but since we were a Disney family, we decided to have our first cruise on a Disney boat to ease the transition. We had a fantastic time!

Now this year, we went on a Carnival cruise- just to see if we would like cruising without the Disney stuff. We did, but there are caveats. For instance, there were times when we were walking around the Carnival ship with nothing to do. That's almost impossible on a Disney cruise. But you do pay for that Disney stuff.

Now next year, we're contemplating going on a Royal Caribbean cruise. It looks like there so much to do. Plus, they are ripping off Disney by having their Dreamworks characters aboard. I even heard that they are having a "Sail Away Celebration" aboard- complete with dancing characters and cruise personnel singing and dancing! Just like Disney!

But if you're looking for a cheaper cruise- you can't get any cheaper than Carnival. And you will have a good time. We did.

Amazingly enough, our 2012 7-night Disney cruise on the Fantasy is less than either Carnival or Royal Caribbean. I have been searching and cannot find a less expensive cruise than what we booked on Disney.

That said, since we booked, the price of our Disney cruise has more than doubled so Carnival is now a lot cheaper.

Book extremely early or book very very late for the best cruise deals on Disney. If you wait too long to get early booking discounts (i.e. if you book within 15 to 18 months of sailing!!!), then the other cruise lines are generally a lot less expensive (except perhaps the Allure or Oasis at certain times of year). That is the disadvantage to Disney cruises - you have to know nearly two years in advance to get the best prices! (Or book within 90 days of sailing and cross your fingers for a last minute discount).
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom