OP,same here I booked me and my DS june trip for CCI and passed on DLh and my stomach has been In knotts ever sense

. There has not been a day that has passed that I keep going back and fourth about changeing to DLH. I have gone many times since I was a kid and everytime we go back we say next time(we will stay at DLH),next time. But I look at It and just can not justfy satying there. We spend all of our wakeing hours at the park,maybe!!!!!! swim at the pool at night. But I love the Disney feel,we stay on site at WDW(POP resort

) and we submerge our selfs with the Disney feel and I am afarid I am going to lose that staying at CCI. Does CCI hold Onto that Disney Magic when you stay there?
Seadd67,
Where do you usually stay when visiting DL? We get APs every other year and then make the most of them, lol, but since we started the prices for hotels just keep going up and up (as an example - the first time we went, we stayed at the GCH and paid $169 & $189 a night - which was *really, really* expensive - and that was only 10 years ago).
We have stayed at the GCH and PPH once each, DLH many times, HOJOs once, and many times at Embassy Suites when we couldn't get a *great* AP rate at DLH.
Yes, staying on-site is magical - I LOVE the feeling of walking thru DTD to get to the parks, you don't have to drive anywhere, etc etc - you are immersed from the moment you get up till you go to bed. But twice the cost magical? Nope, sorry, for us, since we do visit several times a year, just can't justify that. We get to the parks when they open, stay till they close, maybe grab some dinner in DTD, then head back to the hotel to sleep. I think we've used the pool 3 times at the DLR hotels and twice at the Embassy Suites (out of probably 20+ trips).
But, going back to Embassy Suites each day hasn't diminished our trips in any way. In fact, we went to WDW for the first time in Sept, stayed at CBR, and with having to get on a bus to go to the parks and back to the hotel and all, it kind of was the same experience. Don't get me wrong, we loved staying at CBR, but we didn't feel immersed in "the Disney magic" from waking to sleeping like we do when staying on-site at DLR - probably because even on-site is not really on-site in WDW. KWIM?
If money was not a question, I would urge you to stay at the DLH once (though it WILL spoil you into never wanting to stay off-site again), BUT I truly think that you won't have a bad experience staying at CCI, just different!

Now, if there was a bunch of noise going on, that'd be a different story, ha ha, but that would be the case at any hotel.