Never been to Chef Mickey's but so many people say the food is awful there.... and we are going for dinner 1st time soon. So, I'd love to hear more about what you liked. We are going to CM anyway, good or bad reviews, since I canceled it last 2 trips.
So, I can't compare... but Crystal Palace has a wonderful buffet... you probably have already been there? There's plenty of variety for everyone and it's very convenient, being right in Magic Kingdom. The salmon and carved meats are always good. There are about 10-15 different cold salads that are also delicious and interesting combinations and flavors. Far beyond plain macaroni and potato salad. Always good service.