We were on the EBPC in 2008, and Cartegena was our favorite stop. Everyone in my family wants to go back on a PC cruise just for that port alone!
We booked a private tour with another family of four, so there were eight of us. I am pretty sure it was with the same company as the large DIS group did.
Our guide and driver were great. We happened to be the some of the first ones off the ship, and got our pictures in the Cartegena papers. If I spoke more then high school Spanish we would have been interviewed on TV. Since we were first off, our bus (so roomy since there was only 8 of us) was first to leave. So we got to all the stops before the crowds.
Our kids loved the Fort so much, that we stayed there longer, and we were able to change our itinerary a bit. It was great. Being in a small group we were able to hear what our guide was telling us, and the kids were so engaged and they were asking tons of questions. We also went to a local restaurant for lunch. The local cuisine is so good.
Yes, there were vendors in your face (we were the first cruise ship of the season). And our guide warned us about the pictures with animals. We just smiled and said no.
Of all the stops on that cruise, that is the one we want to do again! If my inlaws weren't on a trip during December this year, DH and I would have been on that ship!!
It's a beautiful city, you will love it!
FYI, my kids were 12 and 7 at the time, the 2 kids in our group were about the same.