American Idol Top 20 Season 9

[mandy200587]

Spoilers and Performance order:

Siobhan – Through The Fire
Casey – Hold On I’m Coming
Mike_ – Ready for Love
Didi - What Becomes of a Broken Heart
Tim- Sweet Love
Andrew – Forever
Katie – Chain of Fools
Lee – Treat He Like A Lady
Crystal – Midnight Train to Georgia
Aaron: Aint no Sunshine

 

[ShuisFan584]

I love how AI will be on in half an hour and the talk is about Dancing with the Stars.

Last year and the year before everyone was excited about Adam and David and talking about what their performances would be like.

This year it just seems like there's no one to look forward to. It's just a matter of who's gonna suck the least.

 

[DarthKTrava]

I love how AI will be on in half an hour and the talk is about Dancing with the Stars.

Last year and the year before everyone was excited about Adam and David and talking about what their performances would be like.

This year it just seems like there's no one to look forward to. It's just a matter of who's gonna suck the least.

It's just like during the show we've chatted more about vampires, Chris Pine and other things in addition to the show....

 

[ShuisFan584]

It's just like during the show we've chatted more about vampires, Chris Pine and other things in addition to the show....

I don't even know who Chris Pine is, but I can imagine he's more exciting than the top 10.

 

[DarthKTrava]

I don't even know who Chris Pine is, but I can imagine he's more exciting than the top 10.

He's the guy in the gold shirt in my sig. Played the updated Captain Kirk in the new Star Trek movie.

 

[StephyDee]

Well, by looking at those song choices, I can say for certain that Tim has the best chance of going home. Out of ALL the songs on that list, he picked THAT one?

and as for Lee, Casey, and Crystal, I like their choices. I can see them singing those songs well and I hope they do something different with the songs themselves.

As for the others, I'm not sure. The jury's still out on that one.


WOO! I made it a whole post without going OT and obsessing over vampires, especiallyvampirediarieswhichismynewfavoriteshowandomgIwantthenewepisodetocomeonNOW!

.....oh crud.

 

[agnes!]

I don't even know who Chris Pine is, but I can imagine he's more exciting than the top 10.

He's the re-tooled version of James T. Kirk you can see in the far-left of DarthKTrava's signature pic. Yummmmmmmy.

agnes!

 

[mandy200587]

Well, by looking at those song choices, I can say for certain that Tim has the best chance of going home. Out of ALL the songs on that list, he picked THAT one?

and as for Lee, Casey, and Crystal, I like their choices. I can see them singing those songs well and I hope they do something different with the songs themselves.

As for the others, I'm not sure. The jury's still out on that one.


WOO! I made it a whole post without going OT and obsessing over vampires, especiallyvampirediarieswhichismynewfavoriteshowandomgIwantthenewepisodetocomeonNOW!

.....oh crud.

I agree unless Andrew just bombs it.

I'll say this I'm not looking forward to Aaron's, there is one version of that song I love and it's absolutely amazing so its hard to like it after hearing Josh Hoge's version.

 

[StephyDee]

I don't even know who Chris Pine is, but I can imagine he's more exciting than the top 10.

As the others have said, he's the updated Captain Kirk.

and if you don't watch Star Trek, he was also in The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement. That's when I first became a fan of his. Star Trek just made me even more of a fan.

 

[ShuisFan584]

I know nothing about Star Trek so I guess that explains why I've never heard of him!

Anyways, I think the only two songs I know for tonight are Katie's and Crystal's.

 

[StephyDee]

I agree unless Andrew just bombs it.

I'll say this I'm not looking forward to Aaron's, there is one version of that song I love and it's absolutely amazing so its hard to like it after hearing Josh Hoge's version.

If Andrew bombs it, then he's in the same boat as Tim. It'd be a toss up between the two. Andrew's had one too many chances to redeem his 'spark'. If he can't get it back, then maybe what the judges saw, instead of a 'spark', was maybe a malfunctioning strobe light?

 

[mandy200587]

If Andrew bombs it, then he's in the same boat as Tim. It'd be a toss up between the two. Andrew's had one too many chances to redeem his 'spark'. If he can't get it back, then maybe what the judges saw, instead of a 'spark', was maybe a malfunctioning strobe light?

I think the spark was a low LCD light.

Justin Bieber is being taped tomorrow but going to air at a later date.

 

[DarthKTrava]

I know nothing about Star Trek so I guess that explains why I've never heard of him!

Anyways, I think the only two songs I know for tonight are Katie's and Crystal's.

The thing about this new movie is that you don't have to know ANYTHING about Star Trek. It was a reboot so you don't have to worry about 40+ years of canon that weighed the franchise down over the years.

There was only about maybe TWO songs that I'd heard of. Right now I can't tell who picked them....

Edit: Only Didi and Crystal's.

 

[ShuisFan584]

If Andrew bombs it, he'll be fine. He's sucked every week since the top 24 and has yet to be in the bottom.

Plus he has my sister on his side for some reason...I think she votes like crazy for him. So if you want someone to blame....

 

[Nancy]

I am not thinking everyone made good song choices for tonight.

We'll see how it plays out I guess.

 

[StephyDee]

I can't say I knew all the songs, but my mom listened to a lot of oldies' stations when I was younger. So while I may not have known the titles, as soon as I heard them, I instantly remembered about 8 of them. LOL

 

[Nancy]

At least tonight no leaving to pick up the kid...oh wait...is that a good or bad thing?

 

[Cat0727]

lol at ellen & simon

 

[StephyDee]

At least tonight no leaving to pick up the kid...oh wait...is that a good or bad thing?

a good thing. Why you may ask?

More time to talk to us.

 

[kimmar067]

...uhhhh, EW-W-W-W-W!! Did Simon just say , "We're making out..." ??!?!? WTH??