American Idol Season 9

[Nancy]

She started out as one of my favorites and week after week I like her less and less.. she is my "send home" choice tonight.

 

[Mean Queen]

I hope the judges go back and watch this and regret the tongue baths they gave out tonight.

Listening back, I like Casey the best.

 

[Nancy]

That screaming, eaaaak!

seriously...it wasn't remotely close to being good.

 

[StephyDee]

that'd be great! maybe we could get Tim in the commercial to wash our car too!

YES! the song we'd sing should be the one that goes "Ohhhhhh yeaaaahhhhh" from Yello. It's in Ferris Bueller if you don't know it.


and Siobhan, you were fine until the scream. you.......were......perfectly.........FINE! Now I'll never forgive you for ruining a fun song that I happened to love. I said before that she'd fit this song well, but the scream RUINED IT! RUINED, SIOBHAN........RUINED!

That's MY opinion, though....so if anyone else likes it, that's all good.

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

YES! the song we'd sing should be the one that goes "Ohhhhhh yeaaaahhhhh" from Yello. It's in Ferris Bueller if you don't know it.

i know exactly which song you're talking about!!!

 

[KathyTX]

Siobhan was fun early in the season when she was quirky and cute... now she just annoys me.

Aaron... I think this kid has TONS of potential as a country artist.

Casey... tall, blond, Texan and bluesy.

Lee... I like listening to him. Sweet and unassuming personality, I'd buy his record.

Crystal... love the Janis Joplin vibe. She's very crunchy earth-mother, not my normal taste, but she has a very honest appeal and I really like her.

Mike... eh. Can't see him going much further.

 

[StephyDee]

Siobhan was fun early in the season when she was quirky and cute... now she just annoys me.

EXACTLY! It's like the friend you spend time with, and at first it's fun, but then after a while, if you try to do something funny, they don't laugh, or if you ask them something, they get all snippy, and they aren't fun anymore.

I'd say she's good in small doses, but we only get to see her for 10 mins a week, so you can't get much smaller than that!

 

[Pig Pen]

I don't know..I still don't get the Casey love

It's purely visual.

 

[Cat0727]

EXACTLY! It's like the friend you spend time with, and at first it's fun, but then after a while, if you try to do something funny, they don't laugh, or if you ask them something, they get all snippy, and they aren't fun anymore.

I'd say she's good in small doses, but we only get to see her for 10 mins a week, so you can't get much smaller than that!

I'm glad sibohan went last tonight- at least we didn't get to hear her yammer on and on b/c Glee was coming on in 1 minute.

 

[charming23]

From reading some of your posts it sounds like I did not miss much tonight. I was out and forgot to DVR it. Oh well.

 

[Pig Pen]

i know exactly which song you're talking about!!!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nD16bFaydes

 

[Robinrs]

I just watched the DVR so I could fast forward thru most of it:

Lee: Still the One: Still doing the Nickelback/Daughtry/Creed/David Cook voice. Don't like ANYTHING about him from his dead delivery to his poser voice.


Mike: Ugh, take him and his too tight clothes home. How INSULTING to compare him to Luther... his whole family should sue.

Casey: I like Casey, and I think he was great tonight. I still think he should put DOWN the guitar.

Aaron: Great voice but he does nothing for me.

Crystal: Just okay tonight.

Siobhan: I actually like Siobhan. She's unique, quirky and an entertainer. In the end I am not just a person who likes normal, I like different!!!

Again, I didn't vote. This year is not worth a phone call.

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nD16bFaydes

no i meant that i DID know what song she was talking about.

 

[StephyDee]

no i meant that i DID know what song she was talking about.

I think they just wanted to remind you of the "ohhhhhhh yeeeeeeahhhhhh"


It's hard to forget it, though.

Ahhh, I can see the suds now!

OT, but your sig reminded me......how awesome was last week's Vampire Diaries? I officially love Damon now....Stefan, you suck....literally...and you're creepy....Damon is now the one for me.

LOL I love this smiley. It's so useful. teehee

 

[aprilgail2]

Hope either Mike or Shibihon goes home this week- didn't like either of them.
Casey was really good tonight! I liked Crystal as always and Aaron was good. Lee was ok after the first 30 seconds of the song, those first 30 seconds were painful!

 

[ColoradoBuffaloMom]

Hope either Mike or Shibihon goes home this week- didn't like either of them.

I agree. I liked Mike at first but it is time for him to go home and I've never been a Siobhan fan. Aaron's song dedicated to him Mom made me cry.

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

I think they just wanted to remind you of the "ohhhhhhh yeeeeeeahhhhhh"


It's hard to forget it, though.

Ahhh, I can see the suds now!

OT, but your sig reminded me......how awesome was last week's Vampire Diaries? I officially love Damon now....Stefan, you suck....literally...and you're creepy....Damon is now the one for me.

LOL I love this smiley. It's so useful. teehee

oh ok lol. it is hard to forget. i know...all those suds!!

yeah last week WAS pretty good. but i LIKED Stefan all cracked out on the human stuff, more than his usual boring self, anyway. but i'll always love Damon.....i just don't want him hooking up with Elena. she's too boring for him, he needs someone more fun!

 

[Nancy]

It's purely visual.

Not even that for me.

 

[TiggWDW]

Oh my gosh. Siobhan. Adam Lambert all over again!

 

[asta]

My opinions on tonight:

Lee and Casey were the best by far. Lee was as good as he usual. Casey really came back after a not so good performance last week.

Next, I thought Aaron had a pretty good performance. Not my taste but I think he sang well.

For the first time I didn't like Crystal very much. Her performance was just not that good but she will coast thru based on build up.

Mike and Siobhan were just terrible. I don't like Mike at all and I haven't really liked anything he has sang all season. That scream at the end by Siobhan just caped off a bad performance. I honestly don't think that my ears hear the same thing as the judges. I hope Mike goes home first but wouldn't mind if it were Siobhan instead.