I've been following this thread and it's sister thread over on the photo forum for the last few weeks. Wow! Y'all are making me so anxious to get to the Poly.
Here's my story...
We have been to WDW 13 times since 2000 on family vacations. DW and I have always wanted to go for one trip without the kids. We love 'em to pieces, but sometimes it just would be nice to try WDW without them, ya know.

We've stayed at every moderate, almost every value, but never at a deluxe resort.
I am going to surprise DW with a mid-January 2010 trip. I plan to give it to her as a Christmas present (along with a new digital camera with which to take pics). This afternoon I hope to make everything final with my TA at
AAA. We'll stay at the Poly for four nights, enjoy the
DDP (which we've never had before), and just do whatever we want for 5 days and 4 nights.
I was leaning heavily toward WL, which we have always thought would be a great resort. I'm still sure it is. But there is something about the breath-taking pictures that I have seen here that make me know with all my heart that the Poly would be the
perfect place for us. She's going to be amazed at the tropical flora, the decor, the large beautiful rooms, and the general feel of the place. We've visited the Poly only once before, and it was at night so we didn't get a good idea for how great it appears to be.
I've been secretly working hard these last few weeks to take care of details. Grandparents available to watch the kids -check. Reservations at the kennel for dogs to be boarded -check. Both of our work schedules clear -check. Extracurricular obligations cleared -check. Now I just have to make the final arrangements with the TA. How on earth am I going to keep this a secret until Christmas??!!
I'll be haunting this thread often, I am sure. There are still ADRs to be made, and touring plans to handle. Thanks so much to all of you for the wonderful pictures and accounts of your stays at the Poly. One poster (Sammy?) describes a trip she made with here DH that sounds just like what I dream about for me and DW.