Hi Paulines! Well, I have eaten at many over the years, and first I will say that I am pretty easy to please. That being said, there are only a couple of places I would never go to again of the sit down eateries. For the most part, I find that Disney knows how to do every sort of eatery really well! From the more casual places, like say, The Plaza on Main Street in Magic Kingdom or Beaches and Cream at the Beach Club resort to the super fancy and elegant signatures like California Grill or of course, the posh Victoria and Albert's.
I have had a few so-so dining experiences at Disney Springs, but I have found that some of the eateries are not really run by Disney in the same hands on way that all the theme park and resort places are, so some of these places are like outsourced to different chains or whatever, so let the buyer beware because I could definitely tell a difference in the way the attitude was from some of people in charge there - the pixie dust doesn't seem to reach all the restaurants in Disney Springs, and it's a bit like eating in any kind of city restaurant at times and you can have a cold and rude reception from some wait-staff.
I only mention Disney Springs because people who know I go to Disney often are always hearing about all the new eateries they are opening there these last few years and then they are curious to know if I am going to any of them and then when they find out I mostly avoid Disney Springs, they wonder why. I would trust a new non-Disney Springs eatery before I would try one of theirs. That being said, my favorite Disney Springs places to eat, for the overall "experience" and I very much include the entire outing in my analysis, from ambiance and atmosphere to courtesy and friendliness and professionalism of the host and wait-staff, to the food and drink quality and efficiency to the X-factor - the "pixie-dust", of course, would be Raglan Road and the two kid-friendly places - Rainforest Cafe and T-Rex (more for lunch for those). Those places deliver, in terms of what is promised in memorable ways that are satisfying. Rainforest can be found at Animal Kingdom as well. With those two places, the food level is on that of like a Fridays or Chiles or Ruby Tuesdays - that sort of thing, so as long as you're aware of that going in and don't expect anything more and can enjoy that sort of food, those 2 places are gangbusters for the overall experience.
I also love the Coral Reef at Epcot for the same reason - it always delivers. It's probably a slightly better version of Red Lobster, I suppose, on food quality (I actually think, it's considerably better but others might not) but anyway, the overall experience there, for me, is always magical, the atmosphere and the service are very outstanding and I always have a great time.
Alot of the restaurants in the resorts really are terrific! Try to visit as many as you can and give a try to ones you haven't tried yet, because even the second tier ones at the luxury resorts are really terrific! Like, you can have 3 great meals a day at either Kona Cafe or the Grand Floridian Cafe, for instance, at the Polynesian or Grand Floridian resorts but these places often get lost in the shuffle because of their competition in their same resort, but they are always easy to get into, often without a reservation or on short notice and it's top notch food.
Some somewhat newer places I love in the theme parks are Spice Road in Morocco in Epcot and Skipper Canteen by the Jungle Cruise in Magic Kingdom though I am a bit of an adventurous eater! Which is why I also love all the Animal Kingdom Lodge eateries as well, people flock to Jiko because it's a signature but they might overlook it's sister's resort's restaurant, Sanaa across the way. (Animal Kingdom Lodge is comprised of two resorts, as you may know - Jambo House, which has the signature Jiko plus the famed buffet, Boma, while Sanaa, which is a fusion of like African and South East-Asian flavors, resides at Kidani Village). Anyway, Sanaa is easier to get into, and also does lunch, and if you eat in the daytime, you can see the animals grazing through the windows there, and the food is great.
I am also looking foreward to eating at the newish signature in the Animal Kingdom Park, Tiffins - I was there when they first opened, in Disney, but missed it.
Some of my other favorite magical dining experience are in Epcot, at the higher-end French restaurant, Monsieur Paul, the Mexican main restaurant, San Angel Inn, and the United Kingdom's Rose and Crown. Other resort faves include Citricos and Narcooses at the Grand Floridian, too.
For years, I also did all the character dining and always had a blast at the various buffets with that. Now, since I've been there and done that quite a few times over the years and gotten all my pics with enough characters and I'm pushing 40 (not that there's an age limit on such things) but I tend to want to dine at "quieter" places :lol: Unless I am going with some people that want to have fun, but now I tend to go solo, as well, but if you are into character dining, I can recommend the Crystal Garden buffet at Magic Kingdom for breakfast, lunch, and dinner as being pretty terrific. I used to enjoy the Norway food at Akershush in Epcot, too, that the princesses are a part of, which has a cold buffet of apps and then a sit-down dinner, and other character dining is always a safe choice for like, breakfast, such as Chef Mickey's at the Contemporary or Hollywood Park and Vine at Hollywood Studios.
Sorry for the long post, I can go on and on about Disney dining!