Hi Amber and WELCOME to the Dis Boards!!!
Well, my fiancee and I are honeymooning at AKL this August and we did stay at WL two years ago. We would go back to WL in a heartbeat, but I do like to try different resorts. Since I have yet to stay at AKL, I can only give you my opinion on WL...The lodge itself is absolutely gorgeous and very romantic and secluded. We loved the convient boat launch to MK and Fort Wilderness, renting boats on bay lake, biking to Fort Wilderness, hanging out on a nice little beach where no one bothered us, and seeing the Electric Water Pageant at night. There definetly is a lot to do at WL as far as activities go, and I know my fiancee is going to miss having all of that recreation (especially the boats) at his fingertips, but hopefully the animals will make up for it! The pool at WL was fun, but a bit on the small side, so we would go in during off hours to avoid the crowds. In the hot afternoons we put our chairs in lake at the beach, which was just as nice. But with that, I am still excited to try AKL--I have heard so many good reviews on both of these resorts. I know you will be pleased with either one. Let us know what you decide!!!!!! oops! I just noticed your signature and see that you have already stayed at WL..I'm sorry if I gave you info that you may not have needed. So if you don't want to repeat resorts, try AKL!
Again, welcome, and congrats on your upcoming wedding!!!
--Maren