We love Flame Tree BBQ. A second choice would be the new Picnic in the Park meal. I found this on wdwinfo.com--there's even a veggie option.
You can order your meal at the counter outside the Island Mercantile store in Discovery Island. You can order until 1:30 daily. You will need to allow 2 hours for meal pick up. They offer two price levels.
Tier one choices are Turkey focaccia, chicken wrap, ham grinder or tuna pita. Sides are Chips, coleslaw, corn medley, green beans, mac and cheese, mashed potatoes and gravy, orzo pasta, oven roasted potato wedges, seasonal fruit salad, tomato and cucumber salad. Desserts Apple, Brownie, Cookie, Cornbread, Crisped rice treat, orange
Tier 2 Rotisserie chicken or ham Same choices for sides and desserts. No substitutions.
There are also choices for vegetarians. Portobello Mushroom and Vegetable Wrap on Tier 1,Tandoori Spiced Tofu and Zucchini Squash, a side dish available with either tier.
Tier One Meal for 3 24.99 plus tax 3 sandwiches, 1 side, 3 desserts, 3 bottles of water Meal for 4 32.99 plus tax 4 sandwiches, 2 sides, 4 desserts, 4 bottles of water Meal for 5 40.99 plus tax 5 sandwiches, 3 sides, 5 desserts, 5 bottles of water Meal for 6 48.99 plus tax 6 sandwiches, 4 sides, 6 desserts, 6 bottles of water No substitutions.
Tier Two Meal for 3 29.99 plus tax 6 pieces of Rotisserie Chicken or 1 lb. of Ham 2 sides, 3 desserts, 3 bottles of water. Meal for 4 38.99 8 pieces of Rotisserie Chicken or 1 1/4 lb. of Ham, 3 sides, 4 Desserts, 4 bottles of water Meal for 5 47.99 10 pieces of Rotisserie Chicken or 1 1/2 lb. of Ham, 4 sides, 5 Desserts, 5 bottles of water. Meal for 6 56.99 12 pieces of Rotisserie Chicken or 1 3/4 lb. of Ham, 5 sides, 6 Desserts, 6 bottles of water. No substitutions.
We may try this on our upcoming trip. Hope this helps.