Air Fryer/ Insta Pot/ Pressure Cooker - So Confused!

TinkOhio

DIS Veteran
Joined
Jul 6, 2003
Messages
1,893
With the holidays coming up, I'm trying to decide which type, brand, and model of cooker to buy. I'm not even sure what the differences are between each device! Is there one multi-function cooker that does it all and can be found for a reasonable price? Any good sales coming up soon? And any favorite sources for healthy recipes? What features should I look for?

TIA for any help!
 
Well, InstaPot is a digital pressure cooker, while an air fryer is a small/tiny convection oven.

So, I suppose, the Ninja Foodi if you get one with multiple multiple features.
 
So the “big three” all have pressure cooker/air fryer combos.
Instant Pot Duo Crisp Plus
Crock Pot Multi Cooker With Crisp Lid
Ninja Foodi

Basically you are supposed to be able to pressure cook something then crisp it up in the same pot. What they don’t tell you is that some things (especially frozen meat) take forever to come to pressure, then you have the release time and then crisp time. People rave about how quick and easy it is but I’ve found it doesn’t save me any time. A bag of frozen wings took an hour plus when I could have just thawed them and thrown them in my air fryer for 25 minutes. And *flame suit on* pressure cooked meat is pretty bland IMO and lacks the texture of roasted/baked/fried.

I have an Instant Pot Ultra (pressure cooker no crisp) and mostly use it for things like corn on the cob, artichokes, big batches of eggs, refried beans and homemade yogurt. I rarely use it for a main course and when I do I use the slow cook function. It has it’s place in my kitchen but when it comes to building flavor I prefer old fashioned techniques.

I also have an Actifry (air fryer) and make things like wings, homemade fries, stir fry etc. I use much more often than my Instant Pot. Both hit my counter at least once a week.
 
Following. My slow cooker is losing its electronic buttons.

Never have had an airfryer.

So many choices now.

Also confused and need guidance.

Like slow cooker for red beans and a few other main dish items, but open to something new, if we'd get more use out of something else.

It will soon just be me and dh. But, I do host big Thanksgiving and Christmas meals and use the slow cooker at those times.

We eat more proteins and vegetables and I like to make bone broth.
 
^^ I agree and most of those new gadgets for sale are fairly useless. Crock pots/slow cookers have been around forever and aren't really anything new.
 
Following. My slow cooker is losing its electronic buttons.

Never have had an airfryer.

So many choices now.

Also confused and need guidance.

Like slow cooker for red beans and a few other main dish items, but open to something new, if we'd get more use out of something else.

It will soon just be me and dh. But, I do host big Thanksgiving and Christmas meals and use the slow cooker at those times.

We eat more proteins and vegetables and I like to make bone broth.
Instant Pot is pretty popular for making bone broth and it cut making beans down from an all day project to about two hours start to finish for me. If you want to use the slow cooker function I would suggest one of the newer models- Duo Nova or Duo Evo Plus -the slow cooker function is supposed to be much improved on these. BUT if you use a crockpot often I would get a really nice one if you don’t think you’d pressure cook a lot. “Pot heads” rave that pressure cooking is way better than slow cooking but I disagree. I would own an Instant Pot for Artichokes and beans alone but I don’t find it the magic machine most do. Maybe it’s because I have the time to cook and/or I’m set in my ways. I think it’s a handy thing to have but I use it much less than I ever thought I would.
 
Honestly, each device has it's use. The things I personally use most in my kitchen are my Instant Pot and my Crockpot. I prefer to be a "dump and go" kinda cook. LOL So for me, the Instant Pot (electric pressure cooker) is great for making all kinds of things I would normally do on the stove or oven but in the IP I don't have to stand there and babysit them. Rice, pasta, chicken breast, baked potatoes in half the time, hard boiled eggs, even those dinners-in-a-bag from brands like Birds Eye, just to name just a few of my regulars.
Some people complain as above that the IP makes bland food. Those people aren't doing it right. 😉 You want to use flavorful broths for your thin liquid instead of water. Any powdered seasonings need to be increased a bit because with pressure cooking you are using steam and steaming can waste some of those seasonings.

I don't have an air fryer yet so I can't give advice on that front. I am thinking of putting one my Christmas list so I'll be reading along here to see what people recommend!
 
I have an air fryer and love it. I don't have to heat up the whole oven for two pork chops, and it does them quicker.

What I love it for is heating up leftovers (pizza, fries, etc.) Crisps them right back up!

I use mine for reheating, pork chops, fish sticks, chicken, etc. Ours is an Emeril brand from QVC, and I have a Blue Jean Chef cookbook.
 
I have a knock off Instant Pot. I love it! I use it to make bean and lentil soups and Indian food that would take a long time to meld all of the flavors together on the stove. Keep in mind that most of the recipes you'll find are for the Instant Pot, so if you don't want to figure out how to make your electric pressure cooker do the things that are said in the cookbooks, get an Instant Pot. I bought my parents one on Prime Day this summer. It was a better price than I've seen anywhere, so hold out for Black Friday, Cyber Monday, if you can.

I have an air fryer. I'm trying to give it away. I hate it. I can cook more and cook it better in my convection oven. I didn't realize that they were the same thing until after I bought the air fryer.

I like my slow cooker because it's larger than the pressure cooker (that has a slow cook setting).
 
Honestly, each device has it's use. The things I personally use most in my kitchen are my Instant Pot and my Crockpot. I prefer to be a "dump and go" kinda cook. LOL So for me, the Instant Pot (electric pressure cooker) is great for making all kinds of things I would normally do on the stove or oven but in the IP I don't have to stand there and babysit them. Rice, pasta, chicken breast, baked potatoes in half the time, hard boiled eggs, even those dinners-in-a-bag from brands like Birds Eye, just to name just a few of my regulars.
Some people complain as above that the IP makes bland food. Those people aren't doing it right. 😉 You want to use flavorful broths for your thin liquid instead of water. Any powdered seasonings need to be increased a bit because with pressure cooking you are using steam and steaming can waste some of those seasonings.

I don't have an air fryer yet so I can't give advice on that front. I am thinking of putting one my Christmas list so I'll be reading along here to see what people recommend!
Tip on making baked potatoes quicker...bake them in the microwave for about 4 minutes and then put them in the oven. I use Minute Rice so I dump and cover. LOL
 
So how well to air fryers work? Do they actually make things crispy?
They do but you have to manage your expectations. People get disappointed because things don’t taste like they do when deep or pan fried. It’s the crap ton of oil that makes them taste like that. Air fryers are supposed to eliminate the need for all of that oil and for the most part they do. You get a nice crisp surface with minimal oil but it’s not going to taste like grandma’s southern fried chicken, kwim?
 
Tip on making baked potatoes quicker...bake them in the microwave for about 4 minutes and then put them in the oven. I use Minute Rice so I dump and cover. LOL

I really hate the texture of microwaved potatoes. :) I can do potatoes in the instant pot in 20-30 mins depending on size and they are perfect in texture and flavor. I did some for a baked potato bar for my son's birthday a few months ago - 20 potatoes in 30 mins (they were large sized) and all I had to do was wash them and toss them in the pot. Couldn't have been easier.
 
I have an air fryer. I'm trying to give it away. I hate it. I can cook more and cook it better in my convection oven. I didn't realize that they were the same thing until after I bought the air fryer.

Wait, they are the same thing? I have a nice big convection oven already. I'm so confused!
 
An air fryer is a convection oven. Both use a fan to circulate the hot air, which crisps foods and reduces cooking time. We're a family of 6, so I opted to get a convection oven when we re-did our kitchen, versus getting an air fryer. A smaller family could do fine with an air fryer, unless you're already replacing your oven. Stuff like fries definitely comes out crispier than from a conventional oven, but you're never going to get fries like from a fryer. Still, pretty darn good, though.

I use my slow cooker about once a week, but agree on the issues with texture on meats. It's not bad if you're going for pulled pork or chicken, or something similar where your goal is to have falling-apart meat. I absolutely HATE foods with bones and/or skin cooked in a slow cooker--this may be a personal issue. I love my baked beans from it. I could make chili in it, but usually just simmer it on the stove versus dirtying another pot. I'm home all day, anyway, so it's not a problem.

I have an Instant Pot, but rarely use it. I find the cooking times given to be misleading, as others have said--you have to get up to pressure, then get back down after cooking. My attempts at pasta came out mushy and gummy. I am willing to put this down to operator error, as I haven't really used the pressure cooker much--I had zero success with it. I do like the concept of browning in it, then making a slow- or pressure-cooked meal, but I got so disillusioned after trying a few things, I just gave up.

I would say, if you're contemplating a purchase of any of these, see if you could borrow from a friend for a long weekend or something. A lot depends on your cooking style.
 
Wait, they are the same thing? I have a nice big convection oven already. I'm so confused!
Honestly, convection is better since the air is circulating (if you have true convection) rather than browning the top, shake the basket etc. I think meat retains juices better as well BUT a dedicated Air Fryer can be quicker and it doesn’t heat up the kitchen. If you don’t mind turning on the oven and don’t have counter space or storage space to spare you might not want to bother.
 
*Bumping*

Thanks to all for the input!

Any specific brands/models you like? And good sources for recipes? Black Friday type deals?
 
So how well to air fryers work? Do they actually make things crispy?
Yes! That’s why some people use it just for reheating. I rarely use a microwave anymore. I crisp leftovers in the air fryer, or I reheat in the instant pot. It takes longer, but I don’t have to keep taking things out and stirring. We also use our air fryer for things like ya Quito’s, frozen burritos, egg rolls, chicken nuggets... anything you’d throw in the oven like that. Some people cook meat from raw, but I’ve never actually done that, so I can’t speak to it’s effectiveness.
 
I am a crockpot queen. I use mine several times a week and have several I use for the holidays. I use it for soups, stews, etc.. For the holidays I keep mashed potatoes warm in it, make a spiral ham in it, make cinnamon apples in it. Use it to kee veggies warm, etc.. I love them.

My sister loves her instant pot. It makes a quick meal and also has a crock pot function I believe. I thought of getting one but probably wouldn’t use it as much as my crockpots.

I also have an air fryer which has been used exactly two times. We never really eat fried foods anyway so to me it just takes up space. We received it as a Christmas gift last year.

I think the best one is the one you will get the most use out of based on how and what you cook.
 



New Posts










Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE









DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top