Not a weird question - I too am stamp challenged. I bought a little to/from stamp at Michaels priced 4.99 used a 40% coupon on it so it was cheap. Since every time I use a stamp pad I get a lovely rectangle around what I was supposed to stamp (the stamp challenged will get what I mean), I tried just dabbing my cat's eye liquid chalk onto the parts of the stamp with the letters and then pressed it straight down and it worked really well (my picture is a few posts back of pooh snowman). I also stole AWMs type of tag on top to do the to/from on both those and the mickey ones I just finished the other day. Have to take a pic of those. It was easy and I'm not stamp phobic anymore!
I so know what you mean about that darn rectangle! I can generally avoid it if I use the dab method also. It's nice to know I'm not the only one challenged.
I went back to see yours. They are darling! Now I know what you mean about the AWM type of tag. V. v. cute.