Not sure if they are the same shirts but here is my Kohls experience from last summer. I posted it then so sorry if it sounds like a repeat.
I have 2 sons (yound adults 19 &17) and 1 dh. Kohls was having a very good sale on their short sleeve polos. I remember it so well because I usually get them Lands end polos for the quality.
Anyway I brought 8 polos for all 3 in very basic colors. 3 black, 3 whites and 2 red.
After first wash: All the blacks faded dramatically!! I mean looked almost gray. The whites were fine but I use bleach on my whites so that may have helped. All of them shrunk.

Returned the shirts with no problem and got 3 new blacks, 3 new whites.
2nd wash: Blacks kept their color a little better, not what I would call nice but not gray. Reds looked washed out and once again all shirts shrunk. They couldn't even tuck them into their pants, they shrunk so much.
Now if my kids were still growing I may not mind hte cheapo quality but my husband definitely keeps his polos for more than 1 season.
Polos are an essential in my house because the boys pt jobs require kahakis and polos.
I get them from lands end or llbean now. I rather pay the extra and have them last for a while.