We've stayed at each level of resorts at WDW. My dd, 10, and I stayed at AllStarMu in Dec. I was pretty concerned as to how I would like it after staying at the Polynesian in August. Well....my dd was just thrilled with the place. And I was really surprised with how much I liked it. I say go with the two rooms. Your kids will really enjoy the resort, any of the values, and you won't be spending a ton of money. It will be nice for the adults to sit and enjoy some quiet time, while the kids sleep in the next room!!!