Oooh, tough choice. For us, it would be between California Grill and Narcoossee's. California Grill comes out slightly ahead for its surprising and pleasing food pairings, while Narcoossee's comes out slightly ahead for service. They're even on atmosphere.
Loved, loved, loved Narcoosee's. Atmosphere, food, service all top notch for us. The whole meal was great, but the dessert was stellar. Loved the (year of a million dreams inspired) almond crusted cheesecake!
California Grill was terrific too. Just about even on all points. Loved the view for both. We were there for fireworks for both. Loved it.
I think Narcoosee's was a tad better to me. Although they are both on my revisit list!
Le Cellier was our best meal in December but Biergarten was right behind it. We plan to visit both in October again and we rarely do the same place twice as we want to try them all
As of 8:00 A.M., EST, there is no clear winner for 2007 Best Disney Restaurant. We have a total of 4 restaurants with equal votes:
Jiko
Le Cellier (2007's Most Over-Rated Restaurant)
Narcoossee's
Yachtsman Steakhouse
California Grill and Flying Fish were tied for second.
It looks like everyone has their favorites. Even if I'm off by a vote or two, it's really too close to call. Thanks everyone for your vote(s). I hope everyone got some restaurant ideas for future trips.
Have a wonderful 2008! Happy New Year!