Ok, I think with all the math I have it narrowed down to the above two choices. I was considering AOA:FS, but really the price difference between it and the above are negligible (like around $100)... We are a family of 6 (2 adults 4 kids ages 2-9). Doubt we spend much time in the room, more than to sleep or change and head to the pool (or in case of horrible rain or sickness)... We can get connecting/adjoining POR rooms for our stay (September) for like $192/night/room. With tickets, it comes out to be about $4200. Only issue would be if we get there and they are unable to honor the adjoining/connecting rooms (although I have been assured on the phone that since it is mom/dad and 4 young kids it is basically guaranteed), what we would do. We can also rent points, get slightly better tickets (water park fun n more package - not sure we will go for this option was just thinking that Disney Quest might be a fun activity for a rainy day time - so not sure how much we would use the other benefits/water parks of these tickets either)....and stay at Old Key West for about $4500. Thoughts anyone...this is a first trip, so we are totally unfamiliar with anything.