1st graders homework.... spend $24??? are you kidding me?

I wold be upset about that. Honestly, DH just lost his job - so $24 to us right now would be really hard.

Paper at our school is also a very big deal, there is never paper and they are asking for donations of paper.
 
Also, my 3rd grader has a project where he has to study and do a presentation on Ben Franklin. He has to do the research, and be able to talk about Ben and be able to answer questions about Ben. I thought it was a GREAT project, till I read that 50 of his points would come from "dressing up like the character". WTH? That stuff used to be optional when I was in school. " Come on, DS..just pull out the colonial garb you already have..and wear that." :rotfl: I am not crafty AT ALL..so I just bought him a costume online for $35.

Ahh, dd did that one in third grade, too. The trick is to catch your kid before they pick a person and then steer them toward one that is easy to recreate. I talked dd into being Amelia Earheart. With her dad's old leather bomber jacket & white dress shirt, tan pants, boots, and a long white scarf she was good to go. All stuff we had around the house. :thumbsup2

I actually loved that project. It was so cool to watch the kids become their person.
 
I don't think that any child should be required to bring in $24 worth of supplies; I've had parents in tears in my office (I'm the Director of a Child Development Program) because they couldn't afford a box of valentines. That being said, could you afford the seeds? Is your child's education not worth the $24.00? I'm trying to judge, just pointing out that you could look at it in a different way.

I would be very pissed if I had to pay $24.00 on supplies for a homework assignment and would not appreciate someone saying to me "is your child's education not worth the $24.00?".

With all the money we are asked for throughout the year between school supplies, the incessant fundraising, school pictures, etc., I think asking parents to then fund homework assignments like that is outrageous. Not a larger project but a basic homework assignment. It is a mark of poor planning on the part of the teacher and a sign that she did not think of the families before planning it. Could "I" afford the $24? Probably. Could others? Maybe not. No parent should have to be concerned about paying for their kids' homework.
 
Yeah, I'd have done some glasses and a had him carry a kite with a key attached to the string and called him "Ben". LOL

No way I'd spend $35. for a show and tell type assignment! Gosh, I sound cranky and stingy. LOL

Dang..I should have talked to you guys before I ordered the dang costume! I just got it last week, though, so it's mine unless I want to pay return shipping. I did tell ds he has to be Ben Franklin for Halloween next year. :rotfl:
 
Ahh, dd did that one in third grade, too. The trick is to catch your kid before they pick a person and then steer them toward one that is easy to recreate. I talked dd into being Amelia Earheart. With her dad's old leather bomber jacket & white dress shirt, tan pants, boots, and a long white scarf she was good to go. All stuff we had around the house. :thumbsup2

I actually loved that project. It was so cool to watch the kids become their person.

That's a good idea, but my DS always knows what he wants to do/be before he comes home.
 
Can I afford all this stuff? Sure. Is it a pain? You betcha! I can't believe how much we're asked to "donate" and "collect". My kids go to public school. My taxes are outrageous. Seems to me you're already bleeding me dry.
 
You need to get creative instead of mad. Seeds don't have to come in a packet. Watermelon seeds, apple seeds, call some other parents and share the packets.... hmmm. Show those girls of yours how to problem solve instead of pounding their pretty heads against the wall, lol!


I think this comment (which everyone has ignored up until now) makes the most sense. Share your seeds! Look for seeds in your fruit and veggies! If there's a will, there's a way.

And a lot of stores have cheaper seeds......dollar stores in particular.

Even if you are outraged and angry, try to show your daughters your creative side. That is a far more important life lesson than the project itself.
 
With a son in private school that's cheap for what they ask, LOL! I wouldn't have a problem with it although I wonder why they need so many.
Having scrimped and saved for private school tuition for years, I saw it the same way you did. I would have been thrilled if the "bill" for the month was $24 bucks.
 
gina,

The teacher probably had that in mind when she made the assignment. I would not have written a nasty note and I would have looked into other options for finding cheap seeds. Seeds are everywhere.
 
Dang..I should have talked to you guys before I ordered the dang costume! I just got it last week, though, so it's mine unless I want to pay return shipping. I did tell ds he has to be Ben Franklin for Halloween next year. :rotfl:

:rotfl2: :rotfl2: And for next year too? Its sad how much we do to help the kids. I've learned the cheapest way to do things now. My ds5 and dd3 have the best preschool teachers. They tell the secrets to all the stuff they get for dirt cheap. We have awsome dollar stores around here and biglot is great too. I do read where parents spend so much money on things and I think man I just spent $5 on ours..

We did the seed thing too last year for preschool. We used card board egg cartons for the holders got the dirt from our dollar store and the seeds. Did the whole class really really cheap. Thats why I would love to read a copy of the letter that was sent home.. Everyone is saying that the OP had to pay $24. Now I read it as what was needed and the OP could only get it for $24. Maybe I'm Reading it wrong.. :confused3
 
Having scrimped and saved for private school tuition for years, I saw it the same way you did. I would have been thrilled if the "bill" for the month was $24 bucks.

Yeah but the same way you scrimped and saved, we pay exhorbitant taxes where I live. You also do not have to send your kids to private school so in essence you chose to spend that money. Not flaming but there is a difference.
 
Yeah but the same way you scrimped and saved, we pay exhorbitant taxes where I live. You also do not have to send your kids to private school so in essence you chose to spend that money. Not flaming but there is a difference.
I don't feel flamed...lots of us pay high taxes...I realize it's a choice. Sometimes, though it's necessary. (No regrets, by the way. I just still remember the $$ amount I had to meet each month, while making sure that we never ran a balance on our CC's. Sometimes I felt like a human calculator. :laughing:)
 
I really don't see the big deal. I know the Wal-mart they have here they have seed packages 10/10 I mean the kids get to bring the plants home right so it not like you are throwing away money its something the kids can do all summer long
 
That's crazy, there's so many seeds in a package, each child should have had to bring in one set of seeds, a potting dish & soil should have been provided for all, what you've described is a bit crazy....

On an aside, don't expect your taxes to entirely pay for your kids' projects, won't happen, really cannot happen.... We are in an extraordinarily highly taxed town, but we still have to pay for these types of things, in your case I just don't understand why kids had to bring in SO many seeds EACH... not like they're going to plant the entire package!
 
I think that having to have 12 different kinds of seeds is a little over the top for 1st grade. The teacher should have asked each student to do 4 or 5 different ones.
I have to ask if your child will be bringing his plants back home? If my kids were doing this project I would take it as an opportunity for them to have their own garden at home they could take care of,after the project was done. I would have no problem spending the money for that.
 
But I think Papa said they had to plant the seeds at home, and bring them to school later.

Which is a whole other issue!!

Can you imagine trying to get 12 plants and your kid in the car and having to take them to school if they normally ride the bus? No way the kid can juggle their backpack and 12 plants on a bus.

So now you have no other option than to take them to school the day they're due. I live 20 minutes away from the school, and I rely on the bus for my kids because I'm not driving 40 minutes each morning or afternoon to drop them off/pick them up.


Well, my wiife drops them off at school while going to work, so, fortunately, no big deal.
 
:rotfl2: :rotfl2: And for next year too? Its sad how much we do to help the kids.

No, it's not. It's sad how little some people do to help the kids, but not how much. Children are the future of our country and our world. There are not many things that are more important than that! :)

Yes, I am a teacher.

Yes, the assignment sounds a little odd, I freely admit. I assume that the teacher gave this assignment more than the day before it was due (maybe I'm wrong, though, every teacher is different!) and I would have asked more about it first, and actually spoken to her face to face to see what she was going for. Planting seeds together in class is a whole lot more fun than schlepping in 12 plant cups, so something doesn't sound right to me. If that were my class, I wouldn't want each parent spending $24, mostly because those in my area wouldn't be able to afford it.

However, like another poster, I thought the wording might have been perceived as a little insulting to say: "when she pays for it".

I spend at least $500/year on classroom supplies and I would have spent more because this year I couldn't get paper, chalk or printer ink from my department. We had to get everything on our own.

That's sad.

I know people don't want to spend more in taxes, but look at it another way- with all people already spend in taxes, isn't it a shame that schools are running out of paper in March? Rather than say schools are "bleeding you dry" why aren't people more concerned about how the government is spending the educational money? I know more in my school district goes towards

1) athletics, football field, dinners for the team before games
2) the superintendent's salary, free car, etc.
3) flowers, light up sign outside, posters, decorations, etc.

than to textbooks, classroom supplies, etc.

That's what's sad.

Ask the superintendent when educational monies are going to pay for it, not the classroom teacher.

Until then, both parents and teachers have to shoulder the extra expenses. Quality education for all children is never going to be cheap and easy and we all have to work together.
 
The teacher SHOULD have sent home a note with clues about where she expected you to get seeds cheaper!

That certainly would have helped.

And she SHOULD have assigned everyone to bring in a certain amount of seeds, then share.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom