Yes it was nice to pick our desserts for the Wishes party, but the selection for me was good. I loved all the cheese, grapes and bread. I didn't eat many of the sweets, but my sister did and ate some of mine
I had 3 churros that day earlier so missing sweets didn't hurt. I think for us we loved the table, resting our feet for about an hour and a half and having the view. We were comfortable and able to chat with eachother through the show and know we weren't bothering anyone. We had our picture taken a few times by the cast members and just all-in-all enjoyed the whole thing from start to finish. For all of that, it was worth it for us as a special treat. Because we only go to Disney once every 3-4 years we felt it was worth it.