I also agree with TiggerFreak! Although I have never stayed at or visited the WL during Christmas, I would , no question, vote for WL. We stayed there 2 years ago and it was wonderfull. I told my Mom she would have to stay there sometime because she would love it. That said, I have to admit it is not my type of theming I go for. I prefer light and bright. But for Christmas I would definatley choose WL for my family. It will seem more like home because we are from the north. Also, if you have time, do go to all the resorts they each have something special. We stayed at the Beach Club last year for the week before Christmas and the decorations were very nice. The GF was unbelievable! The huge tree, gingerbread house and just the feel was awsome. Have fun with your decision and ENJOY!