I've gone to this restaurant every trip to WDW that I've taken for the past five years.
I would hesitate to recommend this restaurant to someone who wasn't staying at Wilderness Lodge or didn't have a car. In previous trips, we've been more than willing to "bus it" to WCC from other resorts (this can take up to an hour, considering you have to switch busses at a theme park). But I wouldn't do that anymore - I would only go if I were staying at Wilderness Lodge or had easy access to get there such as a car.
The reason being: it is really inconsistent and the fun has diminished in my opinion. The "experience" is really dependent on the server, and that is the luck of the draw, and this last trip there even some of the great servers of the past wee very toned down.
I'd still go back, as I like the food, (the skillet really is good) and the atmosphere is fun --- but I would never "talk it up" to my kids again, as they have been disappointed several times by poor servers. I would just go if it were easy to get there, and just see what would happen without preparing hte kids, so they wouldn't be disapopinted.
We were there three weeks ago and it was pretty quiet. The kids were disappointed, and our server pretty much ignored us the entire time, not even bringing us several of the items included in the skillet. WE lodged a complaint, but the manager wasn't very receptive. WE had bussed all the way from other resorts, and felt it wasn't worth our time. Or money.
But like I said, I would go again, but only if it were really easy to get there.
Hope this helps.