It's been a while since I've stayed at SoG but I'd like to add my comments as well:
As mentioned all ready, the rooms are large. I believe I read somewhere that they are the largest standard rooms on Disney property. We had a baby with us when we last stayed and there was plenty of room for the fold out playpen. There is a large sitting area and I believe most rooms have a private balcony. The price is phenomenal! When we went last it ran about $59 a nite. It is not *dineyfied* but it is still nice, spacious, clean, and somewhat modern. The staff is extremely nice. There is a good size convient shop downstairs. I should warn you however, unless things have changed, there is only one bus route...and that's to the TTC. Unlike the Disney hotels, there is no direct route...you go to the TTC then make your way from there. As slow as Disney transportation can be sometimes, this "extra leg" can add an exasperating amount of time to your travels.
There also used to be a little snack cart out front by the bus stop. We would always stop there to grab a coffee/danish/doughnut/muffin while waiting for the morning bus. Very convenient, inexpensive, and TASTY! I should also warn you to beware of the dining room. We ate their buffet one night for dinner b/c we were impressed with the menu and price. I am not a pickey person, especially when I feel I'm getting a good deal, but the food was terrible and the service worse. Another poster said breakfast was good...probably cause its a lot harder to screw up breakfast.
The bottom line is do you want the disney convienice and perks without the price tag or are you most interested in the full blown *neverland* feel at any cost? My family will be staying in a disney hotel for the first time this Dec. (not my first time, however). I want them to have the neverland experience so we'll be staying in the ALL STARS MOVIES....the hotel I've heard is the most DISNEY of them all. It wouldn't be my first choice, but since my kids are still young this is the time *immerse* them. When they're a little older and disney is not so much about the icons/characters, then we'll consider places like WL and POR/POFQ. I just don't they'd appreciate it as much (and why spend the extra money if that's the case?)