I voted "didn't like" but that was only after the "room ready" policy started being used at BCV. I like everything else about DVC and may buy at another resort in the future.
We always flew in after 2pm and didn't get to the resort until after 3pm. Before "room ready" we never had a problem with getting an acceptable room at BCV, one that met a request or two. After "room ready" we never seemed to get even one request met, except no smoking which I don't really consider a request. I'm not complaining about a 7 month non home resort reservation, these were 11 month out 7 am reservation calls.
There were too many people whining their way into a room at 9am, bumping someone else out of their assigned room, so DVC came up with this "room ready" bologna and ruined it for those of us that didn't expect a room until 4pm per the contract we signed. As far as I'm concerned the request priority should be to the earlier reservation, an owner perk of sorts, not to some whiner who disregards the rules. Why waste time with a system that allows requests if they don't mean anything?