I've eaten at both and would choose Raglan Road--though I'm probably in a minority because I don't think either are all that great. Raglan Road has decent food and excellent entertainment (and bread pudding!) but throughout our meal, DS kept his hands over his ears. He actually cried a bit because it was so loud. I think if we ever go there again, we'll bring earplugs. I've done that when taking my teen to a concert--we could still hear everything, but it wasn't so painful. At our table, at least, it was incredibly loud.