Most Definately do the Yatch Club!!! Also go for the Annual Passes with room only ressies. Now let me state why and see if I can convince you.
First location, with staying at the Yatch Club you can walk to Epcot in less than 2 min and during the time of your stay the Flower and Garden Festival will be going on at Epcot and is a must see.
You can also walk to MGM studios by the path way which literally takes minutes and is a beautiful walk. You are going to be there at one of my most favorite times of the year so the area there is decorated beautifully.
Boardwalk is just across the way with some GREAT restraunts as well as the Yacht Club having a great restraunt as well, The Yachtman Steakhouse"
The pool at the Yatch Club is the best pool on Disney Property. It's like a little water park.
Night life for you and your new hubby is also a plus at the Yacht Club due to the fact that the night life over at the board walk is going on.
If you get a water view room you will be able to view the Illuminations fireworks right from your balcony everynight.
Just go over to the little convience store on the boardwalk and buy a bottle of wine sit on your balcony and sip on your wine while watching it every night. How magical is that.
Why an annual pass?
Well at the time of the year you are going there are always great discounts for annual passholders. You could get a waterview room for as low as 220.00. This annual pass also allows you to go and come when ever and where ever you please. Plus if you decided to go back within the year to enjoy the Halloween party or the Xmas events you can do so without having to worry about purchasing park tickets. You would also have the discounts again at the hotel of your choice.
I have stayed at all the resorts except for the new Pop Century Beach Club, Shades of Green, Old Key West and the Swan and Dolphin and this is what I think of them.
All Stars- If you need a cheap way to go to Disney AP rates are great 49-69 dollars at times and if you are not going to be in the hotel that much then these do fine. The Movies would be my choice overall the All Stars.
Carribean Beach- To me I just felt that this hotel did not have to offer what it should. The name was attracting to me that is why I stayed but that is all the attracted me.
Contempory- Great hotel however to hotel like. Tall building almost convention center like.
Grand Floridian- TOO STUFFY for me. I must say though it is absolutely beautiful
Poly- To outdated and musty smell turned me off.
Wilderness lodge- I could not believe this was a delux resort. Did not have much to offer for me
Animal Kingdom- Great resort if you have a Savanna room to take advantage of beautiful scenery
Port Orleans- Just ok
Coronado Springs- Just ok with this resort as well as the previous one I would rather spend the extra money on the Yacht club just because of its location.
Boardwalk- Great Hotel, great location however at night it can get loud because of the night life.
YACHT CLUB- ABSOLUTELY THE BEST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Please let me know which hotel you chose and when you come back please let us know what you thought of the one you chose.