Tusker House was the first place I was disappointed in. I had heard so many wonderful reviews and was so excited to go there. We had 8:00 reservations but didn't get in until 8:15. This wouldn't have been a big deal except that we arrived at 7:45 and it was clear that they were just seating people whenever they arrived. We shared a bus with a large group of people who said that they had reservations at 8:30. They were seated before us. Our waitress seemed very overwhelmed and not at all prepared. She never did bring out our daughter a glass of milk. The photographer also seemed in over his head and took forever to get us our photo. The food was decent, but nothing special. We will try it again because of all the wonderful things we have heard, but we were certainly disappointed.
Le Cellier has the honor of being the first "never again" restaurant for our family. The food was good, but not anywhere near as good as they seem to think it is considering the price. We also had a very rude server. She asked if any of us had ever been there before. I told her that I had. She asked when was the last time and I told her it was 6 years ago. She looks at me and says, "So you've never been here before."
She made some recommendations (without us asking) and when we ordered something different, made a face, sighed, or otherwise acted like we were making a huge mistake. Not sure why since the food was all rather good... just should have been a fraction of the price.
We may not go to Coral Reef again. The food was good, the atmosphere is lovely, but the portions are small for what you are paying. No real complaints other than portions, though.
And finally, Garden Grill disappointed us in December. I know, I know. Hear me out, though. My husband and I first dined there on our honeymoon back in January of 2008. Garden Grill was a favorite! We absolutely loved it and told our family that they had to go there when we planned a 4 generations trip in December. We were seated, the food came out, and we were let down. The rest of our family adored the food. They were raving about it. My husband and I remembered it as much better. The character interaction was still some of the best we have experienced, but the food just wasn't as we remembered. We came home and it remained one that my family raved about, so my husband and I talked about it and decided that we needed to try it again and that it was entirely possible that we built it up in our heads as much better than it actually was. In June, we went back and were so pleased. The food was great, the server was probably the best we have ever had at Disney, the food was great, the character interaction was still fantastic, and did I mention the food was great? My husband figure we are in a vicious cycle: We will go and love the food, build it up in our minds, go back and get disappointed, decide we need to try it one more time, rinse, repeat.