Last May, we went to Pizza Planet for lunch..meals came with a very decent sized personal pan pizza, side salad and a cappucino cupcake. My whole family loved it there....you get a lot of food for your money and we all agreed that the cupcake was one of the best desserts we had the entire time we were at Disney. As a family of five, (three boys ages 3, 6 and 8) we were able to split 3 meals easily. We liked it so much, we went back there our 2nd day visiting HS and never tried any place else. (We are pretty picky eaters too!)
For dinner, we went to Mama Melrose and it was fine. It wasn't the BEST meal, but it was certainly good. We are trying 50's PT this year, and are doing another meal at Mama Melrose. If there were a variety of other choices, we would try some place new, but HS has limited options. Rather than leave the park, we decided to go for it again!