Enchanted Garden will be more relaxing. Last time we went to Cabanas after embarkation on the Fantasy, I was juggling a plate of food and a kid stopped right in front of me and had a screaming melt down. that wasn't the only "snowflake" we noticed during the meal.
Couldn't a meltdown happen in Enchanted Garden as well?
The little snowflake wouldn't consider allowing her parents to eat in the Enchanted Garden. (She didn't want to eat at all -- she wanted to be on the Aqua Duck.)
I like the informality of Cabanas. Though in fairness I completely avoided EG for everything.
I was considering EG - but chose Cabanas for the open air seating. It was fantastic.
If you can get an outside table up there. We were stuck inside next to another snow flake.
I wouldn't cruise disney if that were the case. It was the only time we could swim the whole cruise because it was overcrowded the rest of the trip.I was just pointing out that meltdowns can happen anywhere. Your reasoning for EG was the meltdown in Cabanas. Maybe they should just not have the pools open until after sailing is underway. I would imagine having to leave them for Muster results in many meltdowns and the inability for some to hear instructions. No pools to begin with would certainly help in that the dears don't have to leave a fun activity. *runs for cover*