DS5 is a daredevil. He'll pretty much go on anything, and I suspect that he'll soon be dragging me on things that I don't much care to ride. Actually, I rode Splash Mountain last year because of him, and I'm not a big fan of any ride with a drop like that. I got out of going on it a second time, when my mother went with him. This year, mom won't be along, and I'm the only other one in the family that will do it, so . . .
I did manage to convince DD14 (then 13) to go along with us on Splash. I basically told her that at 13, it certainly wasn't going to kill her, and if she didn't like it, then I wouldn't make her do it again. Although I didn't tell her this, I figured if she really started to freak out about it, she could chicken out at the loading platform.
When we got to the loading area, she was visibly nervous, and I told her that if she told the CM she had changed her mind, the CM would let her out. I told her before we entered the loading area, so she had a chance to back out, but she rode anyway. It wasn't a good ride for her, and I can pretty confidently say she won't be riding Splash again any time soon.
Of the two, she is the ride chicken, and I think she lets her fear limit her a bit, so I do try to push her a little. It is a tough call sometimes, trying to figure out what things she is really terrified of, and what things she's refusing to ride just because she thinks she'll be scared.
She didn't go on Test Track last year, but I'm nearly 100% certain that she'll love the ride. The same goes for Big Thunder Mountain, so I'm trying to talk her into both. Soarin' she wasn't too thrilled with, nor Pirates (that little slide in it was too much for her). Although I really wish she'd reconsider Pirates, my deal with her was once she had tried it, I wouldn't make her do it again if she didn't want to, so that is that.
I think that is a fair solution in the end. I certainly won't try to push her into doing something that I know she won't enjoy. Space Mountain, RnRC, ToT I know are out of the question. Rides that I think she'll enjoy if she just gives them a try, I will try to push her into, but if she becomes visibly bothered by it, I'll offer her the chance to chicken out.
DS5, on the other hand, pushes me into doing things, and he doesn't offer me the option of the chicken exit, nor does he allow me to pass on something that I've already done, and know that I don't enjoy