I've had some of the wax melts and scent circles. The one that most mimicked the ride scent for me was Flying over Africa, and it was my favorite. Yacht Club wax melt smelled good but didn't have much scent throw. The Norway scent circle smelled like scented trash bags and made me gag when I got into my car. I didn't like Haunted at first, but it grew on me. I would order it again. African Lodge wax melt smelled nothing like AKL, and gave me a headache. I threw that one away and it made me sad!! Banshee Flight (which is the same as Flying over Fiji and ET, if I recall) was decent in the wax melt. It was probably the most consistent scent throw and longest lasting of the wax melts I had.
Tiki Terrace and Polynesian were good as scent circles.
I recently ordered sanitizers in Pirate's Life, Polynesian, Pineapple Whip, and Yacht Resort, and the wax melt of Tiki Terrace. It's been a year since my first order, so I hope there has been some improvement, b/c I would like to be able to bring some authentic Disney scent home!!